literature review on technical and vocational education

ICT Enabled TVET Education: A Systematic Literature Review

Ieee account.

Change Username/Password
Update Address

Purchase Details

Payment Options
Order History
View Purchased Documents

Profile Information

Communications Preferences
Profession and Education
Technical Interests
US & Canada: +1 800 678 4333
Worldwide: +1 732 981 0060
Contact & Support
About IEEE Xplore
Accessibility
Terms of Use
Nondiscrimination Policy
Privacy & Opting Out of Cookies

A not-for-profit organization, IEEE is the world's largest technical professional organization dedicated to advancing technology for the benefit of humanity. © Copyright 2024 IEEE - All rights reserved. Use of this web site signifies your agreement to the terms and conditions.

Open access
Published: 18 April 2017

Guiding workplace learning in vocational education and training: a literature review

Susanna Mikkonen 1 ,
Laura Pylväs 1 ,
Heta Rintala 2 ,
Petri Nokelainen ORCID: orcid.org/0000-0002-8195-7001 2 &
Liisa Postareff 3

Empirical Research in Vocational Education and Training volume 9 , Article number: 9 ( 2017 ) Cite this article

19k Accesses

41 Citations

3 Altmetric

Metrics details

This review provides an overview of the empirical research concerning guidance in the context of vocational education and training (VET). The study examines practices, providers and supporting and hindering factors related to guidance and learning at the workplace. After the inclusion/exclusion process, the final number of research articles included in this review is 18. Results show strong evidence for the collective nature of workplace guidance, with the entire work community providing learners with guidance and assistance. Guidance provided to VET students at workplaces seems to relate strongly to the activities of the members of communities of practice. Guidance provided by the members of communities of practice opens up opportunities for learners to participate in collective practices by gradually assuming more responsibility and more demanding tasks as their skills develop. The learner’s self-regulative skills, such as responsibility and the ability to take the initiative and to actively seek guidance, affect how guidance is afforded to him/her in the work community during training. Furthermore, these skills may also determine the learner’s prospects for developing expertise in future workplaces.

Interest in workplace learning has grown in recent decades due to the changing character of work and the acknowledgement of the workplace as a learning environment (e.g. Fuller and Unwin 2003 , 2011 ; Illeris 2003 ). In the context of vocational education and training (VET), apprenticeships and work-based learning have been promoted (e.g., European Commission 2015 ). The aim of this review is to provide an overview of guidance and learning at the workplace in the context of vocational education and training. In VET programmes, theoretical studies in vocational institutions and practical training at workplaces should be considered complementary providing different kind of opportunities for learning (Aarkrog 2005 ). The connective model of Guile and Griffiths ( 2001 ) emphasises close collaboration between vocational institutions and workplaces in creating an ideal way to organize workplace learning for VET students. The model underlines that the context and the access provided to artefacts and people influences learning, while opportunities to participate in forms of social practice with different communities of practice are central to learning. Learners require opportunities to recontextualise their theoretical and practical knowledge in new contexts in order to create new knowledge and practices (Griffiths and Guile 2003 ). Thus, different kinds of practices, such as assistance from more experienced others and boundary crossing facilitate learning within and between the different contexts of education and work (Akkerman and Bakker 2011 , 2012 ; Griffiths and Guile 2003 ). Research has shown that close collaboration between students, workplaces and vocational institutions benefits learning (Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ).

In the field of workplace learning, sociocultural theories consider learning as an ongoing, both an individual and social process of participation shaped by social, organizational, cultural and other contextual factors (Hager 2013 ). Tynjälä ( 2013 ) 3-P model of workplace learning acknowledges the sociocultural environment as a context that defines the possibilities and constraints of workplace learning. According to the model, there are three basic components in the learning phenomenon. The presage component includes both learner factors and learning context which relates to work organization and its features including organisation of work, partnerships and networks. Tynjälä ( 2013 ) points out that these factors do not affect the learning process directly but rather through the learner’s interpretation of the factors, which is in line with the constructivist’s view of learning. The process component encompasses the learning activities through participation, collaboration and interaction, whereas the product component includes diverse learning outcomes (Tynjälä 2013 ). Billett ( 2002a , b ) notes that participation in social practices is regulated by the workplace affordances and shapes both the learning process and the outcome. However, eventually an individual, the learner, can choose whether or not to engage in the process of learning.

As a process workplace learning is often considered incidental or informal, even if it could instead be seen as non-formal with different levels of intention to learn, including implicit, reactive and deliberate learning (Eraut 2004 ). Alternatively, one can regard all learning experiences as intentional because they aim at ensuring the continuity of social and work practices (Billett 2002b ). Ethnographic field studies on apprenticeships by Lave and Wenger ( 1991 ) suggest that learning happens in everyday interactions and through participation in communities of practice. However, the theory by Lave and Wenger ( 1991 ) has also been opposed as it neglects guidance and formal education, and is based on the idea that skills, knowledges and practices are passed on to novices. By doing this, the theory ignores the reciprocity of learning and the continuation of learning even after a full membership in a community of practice has been obtained (Fuller et al. 2005 ). Tanggaard ( 2005 ) states that studies on apprenticeship often describe apprentices gradually acquiring greater responsibilities and widening participation in new stages of production, but not much is said about how new skills are taught or didactically instructed. Tanggaard continues that teaching at the workplace is loosely organised as a possibility for the apprentice to receive help and get advice in the daily work situations, and takes place in connection with various social relations. Nielsen ( 2008 ) concludes that important educational interventions and instructional processes are used at workplaces, but they are not necessarily recognised as such.

The use of various terms related to pedagogical practices or interventions taking place at workplaces is heterogeneous and oftentimes incoherent. The concept of guidance is often used in the context of workplace learning (e.g. Billett 2002b , 2014 ). Coaching , tutoring and mentoring are similar activities which all have the underlying intention of providing support and encouraging the professional development and learning of individuals. However, the lines between the concepts of guidance, coaching, tutoring and mentoring are blurred although the underlying meaning of these concepts differ from each other (see Gallacher 1997 ; Wisker et al. 2013 ). Coaching refers to a process which occurs between peers or colleagues and is rather structured and systematic in nature (Gallacher 1997 ). Coaching has a rather narrow focus as it often concerns a specific problem, and the role of the coach is to help the coachee to define and overcome this problem (Wisker et al. 2013 ). Tutoring refers to offering support given by a responsible person within the organisation to a person, usually a novice, related to more practical matters. Tutors have a key role in acting between the institution and the individual (Wisker et al. 2013 ). Mentoring is about monitoring and assisting an individual’s development over a longer period of time, and mentoring can take the form of individual, group or peer mentoring (Wisker et al. 2013 ). Mentoring is also a term frequently used in higher education context to refer to personal support, career development and introduction to professional networks (Pearson and Kayrooz 2004 ). Another concept often adopted in the higher education context is supervision , which takes place when individuals have a long-term task, i.e. a thesis or a project. Similar with coaching and mentoring, supervising aims at enabling and supporting individuals to develop their skills and achieve tasks. However, supervision has a broader scope in that it often includes working alongside with the individual, as well as negotiation and dialogue, to enable the person to take an active role in developing the skills and processes. Thus, giving answers and fixed solutions is avoided in supervision (Wisker et al. 2013 ). Supervision has traditionally referred to a master-apprentice relationship, but lately the role of the academic community in supervision has been emphasized (Mainhard et al. 2009 ). Furthermore, good supervision is characterised by an emphasis on the learning processes and general work processes instead of the product (see Pearson and Brew 2002 ; Vehviläinen and Löfström 2016 ).

In this study, we use the term guidance to describe the support that members of the work community and teachers from vocational institutes provide for students (see also Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ). We also utilize Billett ( 2002b ) division of direct and indirect guidance to describe various guidance practices at the workplace. The social and physical environment of the workplace provides indirect guidance that is accessed in everyday work activities when the physical arrangements assist workplace learning and provide access to observing and listening more experienced coworkers and peers (Billett 2002b ). As much of what one must learn cannot be learnt through trial and error alone, intentional workplace learning strategies, such as guided learning, are necessary to assist an individual in developing procedures and concepts required for shared practice (Billett 2002b ). Direct guidance refers to close guidance and direct interaction between more experienced workers and learners (Billett 2002b ). Billett ( 2002b ) concludes that workplace pedagogic practices comprise three interdependent planes of guided engagement with work activities. The first plane includes everyday participation at work and the organizing of access to knowledge through observing and listening, but also by engaging in tasks of increasing accountability and understanding the goals of the required performance. The second plane comprises direct guidance and intentional learning strategies that are directed towards developing and promoting values, procedures, and understandings. Guided learning at work includes the use of modeling, coaching and scaffolding as well as other techniques to develop understanding and to engage learners in learning for themselves. The third plane of guided learning focuses on extending the adaptability of learners’ knowledge to new situations and circumstances. The use of questioning, problem-solving, dialogues and group discussions aim at assisting learners to assess the scope and the limits of their knowledge and the possibilities of its transfer to new situations.

This literature review presents an overview of the empirical research on guidance and learning at the workplace in the context of vocational education and training. The goal is to provide a holistic view on how guidance actualizes at the workplace by identifying practices, providers and supporting and hindering factors related to guidance and learning at the workplace. The research questions are the following:

(RQ1) What kind of guidance practices are used at the workplace?

(rq2) who provides guidance at the workplace, (rq3) which factors of guidance support or hinder learning at the workplace.

In this article, we will next describe our literature review method and the studies selected for this review. In the result section, we seek to answer our three research questions based on the articles selected for this review. In the conclusions and discussion, we will further discuss the empirical findings from the selected studies and provide suggestions for future research. We will also discuss some limitations of this study.

Method and overview of the studies selected for the review

The research method of this study is a literature review. The review type for this study is a mapping review (Grant and Booth 2009 ). A mapping review aims at mapping out and categorizing existing literature on a particular topic. Mapping reviews characterize the quantity and quality of literature and aim at identifying gaps in research literature from which to commission further research. For the literature review, we collected data by searching electronic databases to identify relevant studies. Search terms included guidance, counselling, supervision, mentoring, coaching, instruction, scaffolding, modeling, explanation, reflection and explorations in combination with the terms apprenticeship, workplace learning, on - the - job learning, work - based, vocational training and vocational education . In addition to searching through electronic databases, we manually searched the archives of journals focusing on workplace learning and vocational education.

In the initial article search, we searched for peer-reviewed articles from the ERIC (Education Resources Information Center) and Education Research Complete databases. The article search yielded 1209 articles from the ERIC database and 1136 articles from Education Research Complete (2275 all together after duplicates removed). We then started to limit the number of articles to those relevant to our study according to our specific inclusion and exclusion criteria. First, we only included studies published between 1995 and 2015 with full-text available and the language of the publication being English. This left us with 489 articles. We read the abstracts of these articles, and also the full texts in case the abstracts didn’t provide enough information for decision making. In the process, we included empirical studies focusing on guidance in the context of workplace learning within the vocational education and training system. We therefore excluded studies focusing on mentoring employees in corporate settings. We did include studies on guided learning at the workplace in apprenticeship education and during on-the-job learning periods in vocational education, but excluded studies in the higher education context. After the first round of the inclusion/exclusion process, we searched the reference lists of the articles selected for the review to identify additional relevant studies. The Google Scholar database was also included in the search at the end of the process, but no new articles were found.

Although the search yielded a decent amount of articles, a minimum number of them actually discussed guided learning at the workplace. Most of the articles excluded from this review covered workplace learning (not guidance), mentoring programs in enterprises or guidance on levels of education other than vocational education and training (e.g. higher education). After the inclusion/exclusion process, the final number of research articles included in the review was 18 (see Table 1 ). Two researchers participated in both setting the inclusion/exclusion criteria and in discussing the articles selected for the study. Other scholars (Nielsen 2008 ; Tanggaard 2005 ) have previously noted the tendency in research on apprenticeship education to overlook issues of guidance at the workplace. The literature search process for this article further supports this finding: studies related to the guidance of VET students at workplaces are few indeed.

The data was collected and studies were assessed using a data extraction matrix, which included information on sample size, study design and results related to guidance and workplace learning. The assembly of the data was guided by the three research questions presented in “ Background ”. We arranged the collected data to identify claims made in the literature. Two researchers further thematized the claims into broader categories, first independently and then together, by comparing and discussing the claims until they reached consensus. Based on the theoretical background and literature surveyed, we then listed the factors of guidance that support or prevent learning at workplaces in a table. We also identified practices that individuals and groups at workplaces typically use to provide learners with guidance. The following sections will present and further discuss the findings in greater detail.

In Table 1 , we have presented the 18 articles selected for this study. The studies cover various training programmes within the vocational education and training framework. In nine articles (articles 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14), the training programmes could be described as more traditional apprenticeship programmes with the majority of the learning taking place at the workplace. In nine articles (articles 2, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17 and 18), the vocational training programmes involved both school-based and work-based learning, with variation in the length of the on-the-job learning periods.

Total number of participants in the 18 reviewed articles was 3485, of which 681 participated in qualitative and 2804 in quantitative studies. Qualitative methods dominated the sample, as they were applied in 10 studies between 1999–2015. Three studies (2008–2014) applied quantitative methods and four mixed-method studies (2000–2011) applied both qualitative and quantitative methods. Participation selection criteria was explicit in most of the reviewed articles (16), but only 11 articles described participants’ demographic data (e.g., age, gender, work experience). Further, only six articles mentioned voluntary participation. Most common data collection method was interview (10 articles), but also observation (8 articles) and surveys (5 articles) were applied. Nine of the articles applied individual level data collection (interviews and surveys), five applied both individual and group level data collection (observations and focus group interviews or conversations), and two articles were based on group level data.

In this chapter, we look into how guidance is actualized at workplaces and seek to identify the kinds of guidance practices typically used at the workplace (RQ1). The articles selected for this literature review introduce a variety of practices through which guidance is provided for students and apprentices at workplaces (Table 2 ).

In five articles out of 18 (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Filliettaz 2011 ; Koskela and Palukka 2011 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Tanggaard 2005 ), guidance was described as a process during which more experienced workers and novices work together: Novices work under the surveillance of experts, while experts monitor the work of the students and provide help if needed. The help provided by experts can involve for example hints and clues on how to successfully complete a task (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ), providing instructions and making sure that students have understood them (Filliettaz 2011 ), and asking questions or providing hints that allow trainees to make independent assessments as to what to do next (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ). Sometimes the trainers can also give somewhat more direct orders about which task should be performed next (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ). Tanggaard ( 2005 ) describes the help provided by experts as a kind of frustration control that helps when the apprentices cannot cope on their own.

Five articles described guidance as an activity of explanation (Collin and Valleala 2005 ; Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Koskela and Palukka 2011 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Evanciew and Rojewski ( 1999 ) state that apprentices benefit from their mentors’ descriptions of the ‘tricks of the trade’ and thereby gain access to information unavailable at school. The process of explanation can also be seen as involving the sharing of tacit knowledge with newcomers at the workplace. The transfer of tacit knowledge seems most efficient when more experienced professionals work together with inexperienced apprentices (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ; Onnismaa 2008 ). Collin and Valleala ( 2005 ) also describe the process of categorization, which involves ‘unpacking’ work-related categories, with experienced workers who explain which topics certain categories cover (e.g. confidential information). Categorization is a central activity of socializing new workers into the workplace and contributes to the building of mutual understanding about work-related categories.

Of the 18 articles, five saw guidance as involving conversations and discussions with others as well as reflection of one’s learning (Filliettaz 2011 ; Smith 2000 ; Winters et al. 2009 ; Wegener 2014 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ). Virtanen and Tynjälä ( 2008 ) define self-assessment as students evaluating their own performance. Discussing and assessing learning, however, occurs more frequently in the presence of others. According to Virtanen and Tynjälä’s study (2008), discussions with other employees are the most widely used form of guidance during on-the-job learning periods of VET students. Smith ( 2000 ) reports that discussions with fellow workers and supervisors are in frequent use at workplaces and help apprentices develop their knowledge. Filliettaz ( 2011 ) describes more experienced workers giving systematic feedback to apprentices and thus inviting apprentices to engage in conversations. Winters et al. ( 2009 ) and Virtanen et al. ( 2014 ) also report on somewhat more formal training discussions that involve teachers from vocational institutes and that include discussions with experts about the meaning of students’ experiences during studies. Winters et al. ( 2009 ) however notes, that during the discussions involving students, teachers and workplace mentors, the potential to engage students in reflecting on their experiences was not utilised. Similarly, Wegener ( 2014 ) notes that discussions involving teachers, students and supervisors don’t necessarily stimulate reflection, as students tend to view discussions as test situations and feel like they need to provide “right” answers, instead of more freely discussing their experiences. Instead of formal situations, students tend to initiate reflection at everyday interactions at the workplace, where reflection is not the object per se. However, according to Wegener, educators have difficulties acting on these initiatives.

In four articles out of 18, guidance was described as a process of scaffolding and fading (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Filliettaz 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Nielsen 2008 ) defines scaffolding as “ a process whereby beginners in a profession are supported by experienced workers so as to improve their basis for participating in a social practice ”. Through the scaffolding process, newcomers are introduced to new areas of the profession and eventually invited to take over more responsibility in the production process. Scaffolding includes the gradual withdrawal of support as the beginner’s skills improve (fading). The articles covered in this review described the apprentices as assuming increasing responsibility and enjoying progressive recognition as legitimate and trustworthy members of the work community. Scaffolding can thus be seen as supporting the identity formation of apprentices (Filliettaz 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ). Nielsen ( 2008 ) states that scaffolding can also serve to communicate bodily know-how (non-verbal scaffolding) to apprentices. A significant part of what is being learned in craft production requires for the apprentice to develop a bodily sense of the products. Scaffold instruction enables apprentices to observe and touch the product, and together with the master to evaluate its quality. Tanggaard ( 2005 ) describes the typical scaffolding situations as often representing a more asymmetrical relationship between the experienced and the not so experienced workers, which can sometimes lead to the apprentice not being critical towards existing practices.

Three articles describe the observation of demonstrations by more experienced workers and supervisors as central to guidance processes at the workplace (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Smith 2000 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Smith ( 2000 ) distinguishes between worker observations and environment observations. Worker observation can be described as “ structured observation of the process being demonstrated by a fellow worker ”. Smith argues that apprentices highly appreciate demonstrations as a method of learning. Similarly, both Evanciew and Rojewski ( 1999 ) and Tanggaard ( 2005 ) state that apprentices found observing the work and demonstrations by more experienced workers as valuable and beneficial for their learning. However, according to, Smith ( 2000 ) environment observation (“ unstructured observation of the workplace to identify visual cues from artefacts, objects, and physical arrangements ”) was not seen as an effective way to learn by the apprentices, nor was it appreciated by the supervisors, who rather saw it as a waste of time.

Three articles mentioned allowing independent work and encouraging students to experiment and explore on their own as part of guidance activities (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Reegård 2015 ; Smith 2000 ). Reegård ( 2015 ) describes the managers quickly introducing apprentices to work and trusting them with a lot of responsibility and autonomy from early on. On the one hand, this was seen as a deliberate pedagogical strategy. On the other hand, independency could be seen as a signal of poor formal training awareness and lack of resources available for guidance. Smith ( 2000 ) also describes the activity of practicing as a form of independent work of students. Hairdressers for example were expected to practice with dummy heads before treating the hair of customers. Evanciew and Rojewski ( 1999 ) mention that trainers sometimes encourage apprentices to attempt or explore a task on their own before requesting help from their trainers. The use of exploration, however, is rare. Smith ( 2000 ) states that the use of exploration is highly valued by the apprentices but often limited and not encouraged by the workplaces because of production and safety issues. Trials and experimentation outside of established work methods at the workplace is discouraged.

In this chapter, we seek to identify the providers of guidance at the workplace. We are interested in recognizing the people or groups of people who are involved in the process of providing guidance for students. The results of this chapter are summarized in Table 3 .

The research identifies people or groups of people as providers of guidance at the workplace. Interestingly, of the 18 articles featured in this paper, only two (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ) mention designated workplace trainers as the only ones responsible for guiding learners. Other articles highlight the more collective nature of workplace guidance and identify different groups of people as providing guidance for learners.

Of the 18 articles, ten view workplace guidance from a more collective perspective and claim that nominated trainers are not the only ones providing learners with guidance (Chan 2014 ; Collin and Valleala 2005 ; Corney and du Plessis 2010 ; Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Reegård 2015 ; Smith 2000 ; Tanggaard 2005 ; Wegener 2014 ). Other members of the work community are also involved in providing guidance for newcomers when they share workplace situations. Although learners are usually assigned a designated workplace trainer, other colleagues, experts and workplace managers also interact with them while they engage in their work tasks. Filliettaz ( 2011 ) refers to this as distributed or collective guidance. Tanggaard ( 2005 ) claims that apprentices often develop a significant relationship with a person other than their designated trainer as an instructor, provided that person is readily available for guidance. Apprentices often build their own networks for learning and choose instructors with whom they feel comfortable.

Seven of the 18 articles mention that guidance can also come from fellow learners (Corney and du Plessis 2010 ; Filliettaz 2011 ; Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Smith 2000 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Corney and du Plessis ( 2010 ) refer to this as strengths-based natural mentoring or peer mentoring, which uses the supportive networks young people naturally build in their work contexts. Peer mentoring involves a more mutual approach and is based on reciprocal relationships and equality. Tanggaard ( 2005 ) uses the term ‘symmetrical instruction’ to describe situations in which apprentices with nearly the same level of competence guide and instruct each other. He claims that symmetrical instruction helps apprentices to develop critical attitudes towards the work, in contrast to situations of asymmetrical instruction, where apprentices might imitate more experienced workers without questioning how they do things. Asymmetrical instruction also opens up opportunities for reflection as well as even technical innovations and new ideas through cooperation with apprentices. Fuller and Unwin ( 2004 ) note that apprentices also spend significant amounts of time helping other workers, which challenges the traditional novice-expert dichotomy and suggests that apprentices can also utilize their prior experience and learning to provide guidance for others.

Five articles argue that teachers from vocational institutions sometimes also participate in guiding the workplace learning of the VET students (Corney and du Plessis 2010 ; Wegener 2014 ; Winters et al. 2009 ; Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ). The process of guidance clearly involves teachers, especially in planning and evaluating learners’ workplace learning periods. Although workplace trainers are primarily responsible for guiding their students, teachers also visit workplaces during on-the-job learning periods and provide guidance for their students through discussions. Discussions between students and teachers are vital pedagogical elements of workplace learning that help to integrate school learning and workplace learning. Setting goals for workplace learning periods with teachers shows the student that he/she must learn at least some vocational qualifications at the workplace. Wegener ( 2014 ) notes that the different kind of didactical practices may also lead to conflicts between teachers and workplace supervisors.

In this chapter, we have classified the findings on guidance and work environment into four categories: (1) learner factors, (2) direct guidance, (3) indirect guidance and learning context, and (4) connectivity. Table 4 presents the summary of the supporting factors and Table 5 shows an overview of the hindering factors related to guidance and learning in the workplace.

Learner factors

The studies selected for this review show that apprentices are often required to work autonomously and receive support only if necessary. Apprentices are largely responsible for their own learning and must often initiate activities to develop their skills by themselves (Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Reegård 2011; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Smith 2000 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Such situations often push learners to develop the self-regulative skills (Reegård 2015 ; Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ) and strong social skills (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ) that are essential to initiating requests for guidance. The work community may however view excessive requests for guidance or being a slow learner as tiresome behavior, which may lead to the discontinuation of the apprentice’s training in the workplace (Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ). Evanciew and Rojewski ( 1999 ) also report that apprenticeships are sometimes even terminated because of the apprentice’s lack of appropriate social skills and work ethic, despite the trainer’s failure to allocate sufficient time to teach these skills. The learner’s deliberate career choice and previous work experience support motivation for and engagement in workplace learning (Chan 2014 ).

Direct guidance

Smith ( 2000 ) notes that the workplace and workplace management can also support guidance by securing adequate resources for the workplace trainer. The trainer should always be provided with sufficient time to make space in the production schedule for training and supervision activities. Support from the workplace for the workplace trainer is essential in order to train and guide apprentices to fulfill a legitimate role in the work community. A major hindrance to the success of workplace guidance comes from a work community that fails to commit to guiding learners.

Support from the designated workplace trainer is an important feature of guidance that has been shown to support workplace learning. First, a close personal relationship with the workplace trainer has proved to be a valuable resource for apprentices. Relationships with supportive mentors assist apprentices’ workplace learning processes. Supportive workplace trainers trust their apprentices and enhance their self-esteem by praising them when they have carried out their work duties well (Chan 2014 ; Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ). Instructional situations at workplaces have the potential to facilitate identity transformation and to provide access to new communities of practice (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ). Instructional situations should include aspects of mutual recognition and identity formation (Nielsen 2008 ). Virtanen et al. ( 2014 ) state that the opportunity to receive individual guidance seems to be the most important factor in producing successful workplace learning outcomes. Tanggaard ( 2005 ) states that the potential for developing a personal relationship with the workplace trainer is greater at the workplace than at school. Workplace mentors are usually able to work longer and in greater detail, and thus to assist in learning, than teachers. However, according to, Chan ( 2014 ) even designated trainers sometimes lack personal engagement and commitment to guiding apprentices, which can lead to apprentices disengaging from their work. When workplace trainers fail to commit to guidance, apprentices receive insufficient support for their learning. Not being allowed to work independently and depending heavily on trainers keeps apprentices from becoming productive members of the work team. The degree of work autonomy can sometimes even depend on the work climate and the goodwill of the trainers (Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). The asymmetric power relationship between a learner and an instructor makes the instructor a role model, which can sometimes lead to uncritical imitation of poor habits (Tanggaard 2005 ). According to, Tanggaard 2005 apprentices often select their own network of trainers who best fit their personality. Trainers’ unexpected reactions to requests for guidance limit initiative (Smith 2000 ).

The research underscores the importance of workplace trainers’ pedagogical skills. Receiving support from a range of different workers at the workplace benefits apprentices’ learning. The availability of workplace support from a broad range of workers, even those with no formal training role, benefits apprentices’ learning (Chan 2014 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). The trainer’s pedagogical awareness and skills affect how the workplace serves as a learning environment. Pedagogical skills also influence the way in which experienced workers are able to share their knowledge and to provide opportunities for apprentices to participate in productive tasks at work (Filliettaz 2011 ). Pedagogical skills can also appear as the ability to share knowledge or to raise questions and initiative (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Gurtner et al. 2011 ). Structured training for trainers is recommended to improve the overall quality of guidance at the workplace (Filliettaz 2011 ; Smith 2000 ). Virtanen and Tynjälä ( 2008 ) state that the pedagogical training of workplace trainers may also improve the critical thinking skills of VET students. Some researchers have noted, however, that workplace trainers show efficient training behaviors even without receiving formal training (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Koskela and Palukka 2011 ). Onnismaa ( 2008 ) states that workplace trainers are also challenged to take into account apprentices’ prior experience and personal goals when guiding them. To facilitate learning, trainers can promote critical reflection, a central tenet of professional growth (Onnismaa 2008 ). Nevertheless, promoting reflection shouldn’t become a way of leaving the learners on their own drawing their own interpretations and decisions (Wegener 2014 ). Trainers themselves must also engage in self-reflection and continuous observation of their interactions (Koskela and Palukka 2011 ).

Indirect guidance and learning context

The research underlines the importance of the ability of the communities of practice to provide apprentices with a supportive work atmosphere. A supportive learning environment includes a social and friendly atmosphere, positive attitudes towards helping apprentices, good workplace relationships among employees and meeting the apprentices’ needs (Chan 2014 ; Smith 2000 ). When other workers are reluctant to help apprentices, there is no guarantee that guidance will be provided. A poor work climate at the workplace affects guidance and the learning affordances offered to the apprentices. If more experienced workers view the apprentice as a potential threat, they may seek to guard their own positions and may be less willing to encourage young people. Competition between workers and the fear of newcomers replacing the experienced workers may compel them not to share their expertise (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Onnismaa 2008 ). Furthermore, Filliettaz ( 2011 ) states that power issues between workers affect the work climate and the learning affordances arising from work-productive tasks. Competition and conflicts between workers can place the apprentice in an uncomfortable position, where he/she must choose sides between workers and the people from whom he/she wishes to receive guidance. In such situations, apprentices bear the burden of always having to be the first to request assistance (Chan 2014 ; Reegård 2015 ; Smith 2000 ).

Several studies highlighted the problem concerning the lack of time and resources set aside for guidance (Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Smith 2000 ). Guiding apprentices is not considered a priority; instead, production schedules sometimes become more important than instructing apprentices. When the main focus of the workplace is on preserving productivity, guidance seldom receives adequate attention (Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). This leads to apprentices having limited access to work operations and only being assigned simple work tasks that will not risk slowing production. Workplaces that focus mainly on productivity often fail to provide adequate conditions for workplace learning. Under these conditions, the apprentices’ learning may remain limited, and the apprentices’ legitimacy, weak (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Smith 2000 ).

A sense of equality and community at work are important factors in learning a profession (Collin and Valleala 2005 ; Fuller and Unwin 2004 ). Non-hierarchical socialization processes and task equality, with all employees (including the managers) completing the same types of tasks, also fosters the integration of apprentices into work communities (Reegård 2015 ). Reciprocal relationships between all members of work communities help to build mutual trust and respect (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Onnismaa 2008 ). Sharing knowledge and skills among colleagues regardless of age and status is essential to the development of expertise (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Onnismaa 2008 ). Relationships between peers at the workplace should also be encouraged, because peer learning provides guidance and support, especially if guidance is unavailable from other providers (Tanggaard 2005 ). Peer guidance is easily accessible and less risky than asking advice from experts, which explains its significance, especially in the beginning of the learning process (Gurtner et al. 2011 ). Moreover, support from family, friends, and significant others, is also considered important and affects learning at the workplace (Chan 2014 ; Corney and du Plessis 2010 ).

In work communities, the apprentice must be seen as a legitimate rather than a marginal member of the work team. Seeing apprentices in a central role also calls for the apprentices to be able to influence workplace practices and to be asked for their opinion. Virtanen et al. ( 2014 ) claim that the more apprentices see themselves as active members of their work community, the more they learn. Workplaces also provide learners with guidance through supportive practices. First of all, workplaces provide support for learners by providing them opportunities to participate in a wide range of tasks, which helps apprentices to develop broad expertise. When apprentices are rotated through different departments at the workplace, they are able to build relationships with many workers and to acquire experience from a variety of work tasks (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ;l Virtanen et al. 2014 ). The research shows that placing the learner in a marginal position in work communities and not seeing him/her as a legitimate member of the work team limits available learning affordances (Filliettaz 2010 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). The marginalized apprentice is offered only marginal tasks to work on and is continuously placed in situations that will not threaten company productivity or security (Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). This denies the apprentice the opportunity to work in important working situations and hinders the apprentice’s learning of more complex and demanding tasks relevant to the development of expertise (Nielsen 2008 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). Apprentices in marginal positions at workplaces also experience little work autonomy. Not taking the apprentice’s viewpoints into account is another indicator of apprentice marginalization in the work community. Winters et al. ( 2009 ) note that students seldom receive treatment as equal partners in formal training conversations. In conversations with teachers and workplace trainers, student participation is too often limited and real dialogue seems to be lacking, as the teachers tend to dominate the themes and content of such conversations.

Communities of practice also support apprentices’ learning by allowing them autonomy and independent work. Giving apprentices freedom, trust and responsibility provides them with rich learning affordances. Allowing apprentices to work independently and then praising them for a job well done substantially enhances their self-esteem (Reegård 2015 ). The increase in responsibility should take place gradually, with apprentices receiving more responsibility and more demanding tasks commensurate with their skills development (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Filliettaz 2011 ; Gurtner et al. 2011 ; Nielsen 2008 ; Smith 2000 ). Giving learners too much independence and responsibility too soon could endanger workplace guidance. Gurtner et al. ( 2011 ) argue that training apprentices to work autonomously is an important objective in many occupational sectors. Unfortunately, this objective often leads to apprentices working alone without an expert by their side. Too much independence and responsibility leads to insufficient guidance and may hinder learning (Reegård 2015 ).

Connectivity

The training programs available to apprentices should be able to integrate formal and informal training, theory and practice (Onnismaa 2008 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Winters et al. 2009 ; Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ). Integrating different forms of knowledge is essential for the development of vocational competence and expertise. Students should be able to integrate theoretical information gained at school with practice at the workplace (Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ; Virtanen and Tynjälä 2008 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ). Discrepancies between learning environments might hinder the learning process (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Savoie-Zajc and Dolbec 2003 ). The integration of formal and informal learning requires close collaboration between various actors in vocational education. Moreover, guidance associated with training calls for collaboration between teachers, students and employers, which facilitates subsequent professional development. Guiding students must not be something that occurs exclusively at the workplace, though teachers often suffer from insufficient time and resources for guidance (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Tanggaard 2005 ). Teachers from vocational institutions should also be involved in helping students to set their learning goals and holding discussions with them (Virtanen et al. 2014 ).

The features of the training program itself have proved to be important factors of guidance affecting apprentice learning. Previous research emphasizes the importance of an explicit framework which defines clear roles and rules for the training program (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Smith 2000 ). Vocational training programs should also take into account personal needs for learning and guidance (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Onnismaa 2008 ; Smith 2000 ; Virtanen et al. 2014 ). Onnismaa ( 2008 ) states that the personalizing vocational studies is especially important for mature students. Having a designed apprenticeship program at the workplace that has mapped the range of tasks and skills to be covered will increase opportunities for apprentices to develop broad expertise when learning is not haphazard and productivity driven (Chan 2014 ; Fuller and Unwin 2004 ). In this way, apprentices benefit from a structured training program and clear goals (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Smith 2000 ).

Conclusions

The purpose of this review was to provide an overview of the empirical research concerning guidance and learning in the context of vocational education and training. The study has focused on identifying guidance practices, providers of guidance, and supporting and hindering factors related to guidance and learning at the workplace.

The 18 articles presented in this study illustrate different guidance practices manifested at the workplace. These practices represent both direct and indirect guidance described by Billett ( 2002 b). Especially observations of the work environment and more experienced workers, and the allowing of independent work and explorations can be seen as forms of indirect guidance. Direct guidance on the other hand is manifested as experts and novices work closely together and engage in scaffolding activities, as information and tacit knowledge is being shared and as experts and novices engage in conversations discussing, assessing and reflecting on learning. The guidance practices that fall into the category of direct guidance can further be divided into (1) strategies that focus on completing certain work-related tasks (such as working together on certain tasks, giving instructions and advice, explaining and providing information) and (2) strategies that focus more comprehensively on the learning process itself (such as reflection and discussions about the things being learnt).

The articles presented in this study describe a variety of guidance practices utilized at the workplace, but also present some limitations in their use due to lack of resources or guidance awareness at workplaces. It seems that techniques that are more trainer-led and easily carried out in the everyday work flow are in more frequent use, whereas techniques that require more time, reciprocality and activity from the community and learner see less frequent use., Smith ( 2000 ) for example, states that workplaces do not encourage the use of exploration because of the risk it will interfere with the company’s production schedules and cause problems with workplace safety. Moreover, workplaces may already have established certain ways of doing things, and any experimenting outside these established methods may evoke an unfavorable response. When it comes to reflection, it has been proved hard for teachers to act upon the initiatives for reflection made by students at everyday work situations (Wegener 2013). Formal training for workplace trainers may also affect the chosen methods of guidance. Some studies (Evanciew and Rojewski 1999 ; Reegård 2015 ) suggest that trainers can provide guidance for learners efficiently without any formal training, whereas others (Filliettaz 2011 ; Smith 2000 ) find that structured training for workplace trainers improves the quality of workplace guidance. Nielsen ( 2008 ) and Reegård ( 2015 ) note that the independence given to learners may also sometimes result from insufficient resources for guidance rather than from intentional pedagogic strategies.

The literature shows strong evidence for the collective nature of workplace guidance, with the entire work community providing guidance and assistance for learners. Collective guidance can also come from fellow learners and be provided by other VET students at workplaces or teachers from vocational institutions. Guidance provided by members of the communities of practice invites opportunities for learners to participate in collective practices (Filliettaz 2011 ) by gradually taking on more responsibility and more demanding tasks as their skills develop. The learner’s self-regulative skills, such as responsibility and the ability to take the initiative and actively seek guidance, affect how guidance is afforded to him/her in the work community during training. Furthermore, these skills may also affect the learner’s prospects for developing expertise in future workplaces. The literature covered in this review focuses little attention on the supervisory relationship between the learner and the trainer. What seems important for learning is not the position of the person providing the learner with guidance, but a well-functioning personal relationship between the trainer and the learner as well as a commitment from both to the guidance process. Whether formally trained or not, the workplace trainer must be able to share his/her knowledge with the learner and to inspire the learner to actively participate in the learning process. The literature also discusses conditions related to the work environment, such as atmosphere, equality, legitimacy and autonomy that are considered important factors for learning.

The research presented in this study describes various ways through which guidance is manifested at the workplace. Students and apprentices receive close guidance in direct contact with more experienced workers, but also the more indirect forms of guidance, such as observations of more experienced workers and features of the learning context, are being described (see Billett 2002 ). What seems noteworthy is the rather high level of indirect guidance described in the literature (see Tables 4 , 5 ). The literature does present ways through which direct guidance is offered, but also brings forward many limitations and hindering factors for the guidance of VET students, such as lack of time and resources set aside for guidance. This raises a question about whether the indirect forms of guidance become more common in case workplaces fail at allocating adequate resources for guidance. Whether it is the resources, established ways of working and learning or the availability of pedagogical expertise that shapes guidance practices at workplaces, further research needs to evaluate the usefulness and value of these practices from a learner’s point of view while taking into account the wide variation in learning environments (see Fuller and Unwin 2003 ) and the realities of everyday work situations.

To improve learning at work, guidance at workplaces must be part of a legitimate and established process that the broad work community is committed to providing. More attention needs to be focused on what the learner has to offer to the supervisory relationship and the skills and knowledge he/she brings to it. Even if the master-novice relationship and, in some cases, the professional monopoly on expertise remains important, the school also needs to encourage its teachers and students to cross boundaries between the school and workplace (Tuomi-Gröhn et al. 2003 ). Students may act as crucial change agents who carry, translate and help to implement new ideas between the educational institution and the workplace (Engeström 2011 ). There is a need to challenge the role of factors such as age and status in defining the concept of expert (e.g.Fuller and Unwin 2004 ) in order to support reciprocal learning.

A company’s approach to the development of individual expertise is likely to be influenced by a range of factors, including the product market in which it is located, as well as the organization of the work and the distribution of skills (Fuller and Unwin 2004 ). If companies fail to map the range of skills to be covered, learning risks becoming haphazard and is more likely to be driven by the need to preserve company productivity (Chan 2014 ; Fuller and Unwin 2004 ; Smith 2000 ). Guidance should be recognized as an important task to be carried out at the workplace. When the processes of guidance in the work community become transparent, both learners and other members of the work community become more aware of the objectives of VET students’ workplace learning, thereby supporting the allocation of adequate resources for guidance. A structured training program makes the training objectives more transparent for both the learner and the work community.

From a methodological perspective, reviewed articles used in most cases basic qualitative (e.g., content analysis) and quantitative (descriptive statistics) analysis methods. Only 11 articles contained both explanation and justification of selected methodological approach and explicit description of data analysis. In practice this means that only these studies could be properly replicated in the future. Only eight articles had a section about critical examination of the method(s) and limitations of the study. This is quite surprising, as all the reviewed articles were published in peer-reviewed journals. Group level data collection was applied in eight articles, but we found very little discussion about rationale of choosing such approach and related validity issues (see, e.g., Chioncel et al. 2003 ). Although quantitative studies in this review were based on cross-sectional design, we were delighted to see that most of the qualitative articles included components of longitudinal design (data collection varied from 1 month to 4 years). Only one study contained intervention, but that was non-controlled (retrospective). To conclude, future studies should pay more attention to methodological issues (clear argumentation why a certain design and related analysis methods were chosen; detailed description of participants, procedure and analyses) in order to minimise bias in results and recommendations.

Limitations

We want to acknowledge that, like all studies, this study has certain limitations. First , the number of articles related to workplace guidance in the context of vocational education turned out to be surprisingly small. Studies focusing primarily on guidance were rare, and in many of the studies selected for this review, guidance was something observed alongside other things, but was not the main focus. However, the cumulative results nevertheless suggest, that we managed to capture the main themes related to workplace guidance in the literature. Second , because the number of original articles that fit the inclusion/exclusion criteria was so small, we included them all in order to obtain versatile information about our topic. Thus, it is worth noting that the original articles themselves have certain limitations. In most studies, the sample size was relatively small, which is not unusual for qualitative interviews and case studies, which many of these studies represent. Although articles investigated many interesting aspects of workplace guidance, methodological robustness was not in all cases clearly opened for a reader; we found lack of detail in participant information, methodological choices and also how the analyses were conducted. This clearly limited our ability to judge importance and validity of the results and practical recommendations. Third , most of the studies featured in this paper failed either to take into account the specific features of different vocational fields or to compare the guidance afforded to learners in the different learning environments of specific vocations. Given the differences noted between different fields of vocational education (e.g. social and health care vs. technology), generalizing the results from one field to another may be questionable (Virtanen et al. 2014 ). Consequently, we recommend devoting more research to compare how these different field-specific learning environments affect the guidance provided to learners.

Aarkrog V (2005) Learning in the workplace and the significance of school-based education: a study of learning in a Danish vocational education and training programme. Int J Lifelong Educ 24(2):137–147

Article Google Scholar

Akkerman SF, Bakker A (2011) Boundary crossing and boundary objects. Rev Educ Res 81(2):132–169

Akkerman SF, Bakker A (2012) Crossing boundaries between school and work during apprenticeships. Voc Learn 5(2):153–173

Billett S (2002a) Toward a workplace pedagogy: guidance, participation and engagement. Adult Educ Q 53(1):27–43

Billett S (2002b) Workplace pedagogic practices: co-participation and learning. Br J Educ Stud 50(4):457–481

Billett S (2014) Mimesis: learning through everyday activities and interactions at work. Human Res Dev Rev 13(4):462–482

Chan S (2014) Belonging to a workplace: first-year apprentices’ perspectives on factors determining engagement and continuation through apprenticeship. Int J Educ Voc Guid. doi: 10.1007/s10775-014-9282-2

Google Scholar

Canfield A (1980) Learning styles inventory manual. Humanics Media, Ann Arbor, MI

Chioncel NE, Van Der Veen RGW, Wildemeersch D, Jarvis P (2003) The validity and reliability of focus groups as a research method in adult education. Int J Lifelong Educ 22(5):495–517

Collin K, Valleala U-M (2005) Interaction among employees: how does learning take place in the social communities of the workplace and how might such learning be supervised? J Educ Work 18(4):401–420

Corney T, du Plessis K (2010) Apprentices’ mentoring relationships. the role of significant others’ and supportive relationships across the work-life domains. Youth Stud Aust 29(3):18–26

Engeström Y (2011) From design experiments to formative interventions. Theory Psychol 21(5):598–629

Eraut M (2004) Informal learning in the workplace. Stud Cont Educ 26(2):247–273

European Commission (2015) High-performance apprenticeships & work-based learning: 20 guiding principles. http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=1147&langId=fi&moreDocuments=yes

Evanciew C, Rojewski J (1999) Skill and knowledge acquisition in the workplace: a case study of mentor-apprentice relationships in youth apprenticeship programs. J Ind Teach Educ 36(2):24–53

Filliettaz L (2010) Guidance as an interactional accomplishment. practice-based learning within the swiss VET system. In: Billett S (ed) Learning through practice. Professional and practice-based learning. Springer, New York, pp 156–179

Filliettaz L (2011) Collective guidance at work: a resource for apprentices? J Voc Educ Work 63(3):485–504

Filliettaz L, Durand I, Trebert D (2015) Learning through verbal interactions in the workplace: the role and place of guidance in vocational education and training. In: Filliettaz L, Billett S (eds) Francophone perspectives of learning through work: conceptions, traditions and practices. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 279–301

Chapter Google Scholar

Fuller A, Unwin L (2003) Learning as Apprentices in the contemporary UK workplace: creating and managing expansive and restrictive participation. J Educ Work 16(4):407–426

Fuller A, Unwin L (2004) Young people as teachers and learners in the workplace: challenging the novice-expert dichotomy. Int J Train Dev 8(1):32–42

Fuller A, Unwin L (2011) Workplace learning and the organization. In: Malloch M, Cairns L, Evans K, O’Connor BN (eds) The sage handbook of workplace learning. Sage, London, pp 46–59

Fuller A, Hodkinson H, Hodkinson P, Unwin L (2005) Learning as peripheral participation in communities of practice: a reassessment of key concepts in workplace learning. Br Educ Res J 31(1):49–68

Gallacher K (1997) Supervision, mentoring, and coaching: methods for supporting personnel development. In: Winton PL, McCollum JA, Catletts C (eds) Reforming personnel preparation in early intervention: issues, models, and practical strategies. Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co, Washington, pp 191–214

Grant M, Booth A (2009) A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Inf Libr J 26:91–108

Griffiths T, Guile D (2003) A connective model of learning: the implications for work process knowledge. Eur Educ Res J 2(1):56–73

Guile D, Griffiths T (2001) Learning through work experience. J Educ Work 14(1):113–131

Gurtner J-L, Cattaneo A, Motta E, Mauroux L (2011) How often and for what purposes apprentices seek help in workplaces: a mobile technology-assisted study. Voc Learn 4(2):113–131

Hager P (2013) Theories of workplace learning. In: Malloch M, Cairns L, Evans K, O’Connor B (eds) The SAGE handbook of workplace learning. Sage, London, pp 17–32

Illeris K (2003) Workplace learning and learning theory. J Workplace Learn 15(4):167–178

Koskela I, Palukka H (2011) Trainer interventions as instructional strategies in air traffic control training. J Workplace Learn 23(5):293–314

Lave J, Wenger E (1991) Situated learning: legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Book Google Scholar

Mainhard T, van der Rijst R, van Tartwijk J, Wubbels T (2009) A model for the supervisor–doctoral student relationship. High Educ 58(3):359–373

Nielsen K (2008) Scaffold instruction at the workplace from a situated perspective. Stud Cont Educ 30(3):247–261

Onnismaa J (2008) Age, experience, and learning on the job: crossing the boundaries between training and workplace. J Employ Couns 45(2):79–90

Pearson M, Brew A (2002) Research training and supervision development. Stud High Educ 27(2):135–150

Pearson M, Kayrooz C (2004) Enabling critical reflection on research supervisory practice. Int J Acad Dev 9(1):99–116

Reegård K (2015) Sales assistants in the making: learning through responsibility. Voc Learn 8(2):117–133

Savoie-Zajc L, Dolbec A (2003) Co-operative education in the pulp and paper sector in Quebec. J Workplace Learn 15(3):114–122

Scandura TA, Ragins BR, Scandura TA, Ragins BR (1993) The effects of sex and gender role orientation on mentorship in male-dominated occupations. J Vocat Behav 43:251–265

Smith P (2000) Flexible delivery and apprentice training: preferences, problems and challenges. J Voc EducTrain 52(3):483–503

Tanggaard L (2005) Collaborative teaching and learning in the workplace. J Voc Educ Train 57(1):109–122

Tuomi-Gröhn T, Engeström Y, Young M (2003) From transfer to boundary-crossing between school and work as a tool for developing vocational education: an introduction. In: Tuomi-Gröhn T, Engeström Y (eds) Between school and work: new perspectives on transfer and boundary-crossing. Pergamon Press, Amsterdam, pp 1–19

Tynjälä P (2013) Toward a 3-P model of workplace learning: a literature review. Voc Learn 6(1):11–36

Tynjälä P, Virtanen A (2005) Skill learning at work: investigations into student experiences of on-the-job learning. Learning the skills. Special edition of the Finnish Journal of Vocational and Professional Education, pp 106–116

Vehviläinen S, Löfström E (2016) ‘I wish I had a crystal ball’: discourses and potentials for developing academic supervising. Stud High Educ 41(3):508–524

Virtanen A, Tynjälä P (2006) Workplace learning in Finnish VET: students’, teachers’ and workplace trainers’ perspectives. Paper presented at the EARLI SIG professional learning and development conference, 11–13 October 2006. Heerlen, the Netherlands

Virtanen A, Tynjälä P (2008) Students’ experiences of workplace learning in finnish VET. European J Voc Train 44(2):200–213

Virtanen A, Tynjälä P, Eteläpelto A (2014) Factors promoting vocational students’ learning at work: study on student experiences. J Educ Work 27(1):43–70

Wegener C (2014) A situated approach to VET students’ reflection processes across boundaries. J Educ Work 27(4):454–473

Winters A, Meijers F, Kuijpers M, Baert H (2009) What Are Vocational training conversations about? analysis of vocational training conversations in Dutch vocational education from a career learning perspective. J Voc Educ Train 61(3):247–266

Wisker G, Exley K, Antoniou M, Ridley P (2013) Working one-to-one with students: supervising, coaching, mentoring, and personal tutoring. Routledge, New York

Download references

Authors’ contributions

All authors participated in design of the study and writing of the research report. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

Competing interests.

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Availability of data and materials

Data is available in anonymized form from the corresponding author upon request.

Consent for publication

Authors declare that they have approved manuscript for submission, and the content of the manuscript has not been published, of submitted for publication elsewhere.

Research was funded by Academy of Finland (Grant 303693).

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

School of Education, University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland

Susanna Mikkonen & Laura Pylväs

Industrial Information Management Laboratory, Tampere University of Technology, Tampere, Finland

Heta Rintala & Petri Nokelainen

Institute of Behavioural Sciences, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland

Liisa Postareff

You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Petri Nokelainen .

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article.

Mikkonen, S., Pylväs, L., Rintala, H. et al. Guiding workplace learning in vocational education and training: a literature review. Empirical Res Voc Ed Train 9 , 9 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40461-017-0053-4

Download citation

Received : 30 June 2016

Accepted : 01 April 2017

Published : 18 April 2017

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1186/s40461-017-0053-4

Share this article

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

Workplace learning
Apprenticeship education
Literature review

literature review on technical and vocational education

Jordan Technical and Vocational Education and Training System Review 2023

In 2023, UNESCO undertook the TVET System Review of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, under the leadership of the Ministry of Education (MoE) and in consultation with a wide range of national and international stakeholders. The Review aimed to guide the implementation of MoE’s technical and vocational education and training (TVET) reforms and inform on the relevance, effectiveness, impact, and sustainability of vocational education outcomes compared to active labour-market needs.

Skill development has been a growing priority in Jordan’s national development agenda, with TVET positioned to play a key role in achieving Jordan’s 2025 Vision and the strategic objectives of Jordan’s Economic Modernisation Vision (EMV) 2022–2033. The labour market in Jordan is characterized by relatively high unemployment and constrained by serious skill gaps and shortages, suggesting that the education and training system – including TVET – is not fully meeting labour market needs. Moreover, several other challenges continue to limit the effectiveness of TVET in Jordan.

Despite challenges, there are several recent achievements, such as the newly endorsed strategies and plans that aim to improve the relevance and quality of TVET and diversify programme specializations to better reflect labour market needs.

Over 100 people from more than 50 public, private, non-governmental and international entities were consulted, and around 120 documents (legal acts, regulations, strategies, action plans, reports, studies, methodologies, datasets, etc.) were analysed in the Review. Consultations included key stakeholders within the MoE, the Ministry of Labour, the Technical and Vocational Skill Development Commission (TVSDC), national skills councils, and visits to training centres, universities, and workplaces. On 8 June 2023, a validation workshop was hosted in Amman by the MoE and UNESCO, during which a draft version of the Review was presented to the key TVET stakeholders, and feedback was compiled to finalize the Review report.

Findings and conclusions from the Review are summarized below:

The increasing demographic and labour-market pressures impact the TVET sector in Jordan.

There is a presence of a large informal sector, which accounts for close to 15 per cent of the economy and over 50 per cent of employment, resulting in revenue losses for the public sector and decent-work deficits for workers.

The private sector is dominated by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) with limited capacity to create new employment opportunities.

The Jordanian economy has a limited capacity to generate sufficient employment opportunities for new labour-market entrants.

High unemployment persists, particularly among young people in the 15–24 age group, particularly women. On the other hand, 64 per cent of those employed are employed in roles that are classified as medium-skilled and are typically supported by vocational education and training.

The transition from school to work for young people remains fraught, and persisting expectations of public employment are increasing their economic inactivity, with many graduates queueing for public-sector jobs.

Public perception of TVET as a pathway to decent work is poor, as evidenced by the low enrolment rates and employment outcomes.

Annual funding allocated to TVET, including for pre- and in-service teacher training, is limited, and the limited number of vocational schools under MoE with up-to-date equipment to deliver practical training require substantial investment.

Private-sector involvement in the development, delivery, and assessment of TVET curricula and programmes is weak. Addressing the skills mismatch and improving the relevance of TVET to both employers and students in Jordan are very critical in enhancing the demand over TVET and the quality of its delivery.

Evidence-based policymaking on TVET and skills for employment is not well-developed, given the lack of an integrated information system for labour-market and skills intelligence to inform decision-making.

The TVET System Review compiles key recommendations in relation to the TVET system of Jordan such as:

Strengthening governance and coordination across the key stakeholders covering the entire skill ecosystem in Jordan.

Ensuring the relevance of TVET to labour-market needs to reduce skills mismatch.

Supporting TVET learners’ transition to the labour market and promote lifelong learning through improved pathways and expanded career guidance and development.

Updating qualifications, curricula and teaching/learning materials, and support teachers in delivering them.

Improving industry engagement by strengthening links between TVET providers and workplaces.

Establishing a system to ensure sustainable funding to support TVET systems.

Ensuring equity and increase female participation in TVET.

Download the full report and summary:

Arabic full report: LINK

Arabic summary: LINK

English full report: LINK

English summary: LINK

More on this subject

UNESCO International Forum on the Futures of Education 2024

A Literature Review Technical and vocational education Abstract

2016, Journal for Studies in Management and Planning

Technical and vocational education is considered as an important measure for the development of trained labor force which are required for the economic growth of a country. The aim of this paper is to examine the problems and strategies for revamping technical and vocational education in Nigeria. This paper made use of various evidences collected through the secondary sources of data collection. Findings from this paper showed that there is plethora of problems militating against technical and vocational education in Nigeria. They include wrong perception, societal stigma, poor funding, dearth of qualified technical and vocational personnel, epileptic power supply, lack of indigenous technical and vocational education text books, poor student motivation, lack of continuity, poor teaching methods employed by teacher, amongst other. In addition to this, the study also revealed that flexible workable and adaptable programmes schedule are the necessary strategies for revamping technical and vocational education in Nigeria. The paper concluded that government and private organizations should adequately support the funding of technical and vocational education in order to reduce the menace of graduate unemployment in the country.

Related Papers

Nzube Cyril Muoghalu

Nzube C Y R I L Muoghalu

Abstract This paper reviews the Challenges of Technical and Vocational Education in Nigeria. The paper discusses the issue of increasing rate of unemployment in the country as a neglect of this programme by both government and citizens of Nigeria. Challenges of Technical and Vocational education programmes in Nigeria are identified to include Institutions’ Leadership and Priority, Inadequate Supply of Technical Teachers, Inadequate Provision of Instructional Materials and Workshop Facilities, Inadequate funding, Social Appraisal or Poor societal perception, Too much emphasis on University education/Paper Qualification/Certification, Lack of partnership or collaboration of private sectors, Poor Practical/Technical Skills, Terrorism/Insecurity, Weak monitoring and evaluation, Epileptic power supply, Information and Communication Technology and Proliferation of Educational Courses in Colleges of Education (Technical) in Nigeria. Recommendations were also made.

Brian Jolly

DANCUN MIRANGA

Technical education, as enshrined in the Nigerian national policy on education, is concerned with qualitative technological human resources development directed towards a national pool of skilled and self reliant craftsmen, technicians and technologists in technical and vocational education fields. In Nigeria, the training of technical personnel has witnessed many challenges ranging from policies which have no beaming with our problems, curriculum that has little or no relationship with workplace and social needs, embezzlement of fund meant for education development purposes, lack of teacher motivation, inadequate facilities, inadequate funding, brain drain, poor staff training , bribery and corruption. This paper intends to critically examine some of the issues, challenges and way forward of technical, vocational education and training(TVET) in Nigeria and to suggest ways of improving the teaching and learning of technical and vocational education with greater interest and enthusiasm.

PAULINUS OKWELLE

Nigeria's unemployment situation and economic backwardness have always been tied to the nation's educational system which many believe lacks pedagogical practices, entrepreneurial competencies, and poor competency-based curricula with resultant effect of producing graduates lacking saleable skills to engender self-reliance or paid employment. The thrust of this paper therefore, was to awaken the consciousness of the Nigeria populace especially those who are directly involved in the educational process to this deplorable state of education and to chart the way to ameliorating it. In doing this, the paper reviewed the current problem and issues in Nigeria educational system with particular insight into issues of curricula and professional teacher's roles in the knowledge based economy. Based on the issues raised, the authors attempted to prove that there is no substitute to technical vocational education and training (TVET) as the education that matters; viable enough in all respects to drive all forces and factors necessary for attaining national greatness and for improved national economy. As a way forward, it was recommended that the Nigerian government should explicitly support and be fully committed to the development and expansion of TVET at all levels and to the strengthening of TVET links with the labour market.

The Sixth Asian Conference on Education - Official Conference Proceedings

Noah Oyedeji

Emmanuel Achor

This paper examined the present status of Vocational and Technical Education (VTE) in Nigeria with particular emphasis on the attainment of national educational goals. Some VTE related goals as enshrined in the National Policy on Education include (i) introduction in to world of technology, (ii) acquiring technical skills, (iii) exposing students to career awareness and (iv) enabling youths to have an intelligent understanding of the increasing complexity of technology. While the paper has the conviction that there is adequate policy backing to VTE programmes in Nigeria, it posited that the issue with VTE is not that of inadequacy of curriculum content but that there are gaps in implementation and funding. Consequently, the poor implementation and funding leads to production of graduates that are ill prepared to face the entrepreneurial expectations of the profession. It is recommended that there should be removal of deregulation on VTE imported items, adequate funding of UBE programmes which invariably favours VTE and introduction of one year industrial attachment for VTE students from tertiary institutions in Nigeria before they are awarded certificates.

Journal of Emerging Trends in Educational Research and Policy Studies (JETERAPS) 7(2): 125-133

Osinachi A N T H O N Y Okorafor

Nigeria adopted education as an instrument for national development. After hundred years of existence, Nigeria has made less than impressive progress in economic development. It has blamed the poor performance of its educational system, in meeting the national development goals, on the inherited colonial type of education. A good number of educational reforms have taken place and Technical Vocational Education and Training (TVET) has been recognized as a key player in achieving the much needed aspiration of the nation. However, it has not been accorded the appropriate attention, so as, for it to play its role in national development. The purpose of this study therefore is to examine the development needs of Nigeria and the need for functional education system particularly TVET. It examines the foundation of TVET in Nigeria, what has been done so far concerning TVET, the challenges of TVET; and then proposes how to strengthen TVET to play its role in transforming the Nigerian State.

NIGERIA'S TECHNICAL, VOCATIONAL EDUCATION, AND TRAINING PROGRAMS- Insights and Analysis

Daniels Akpan

This report presents a comprehensive evaluation of Nigeria's vocational education and training (TVET) programs, shedding light on both their remarkable contributions and ongoing challenges. While TVET has significantly benefited workforce development, economic growth, poverty reduction, and social inclusion, this research underlines the persistent obstacles inhibiting its full potential. The report delves into the historical evolution of TVET in Nigeria and thoroughly examines the regulatory frameworks, legislation, and organizations established to support its growth, highlighting the collaborative endeavors involving government, for-profit, and non-profit entities. It further assesses the effectiveness, challenges, and potential of the country's technical education system, exploring market dynamics and showcasing innovative institutions. Ultimately, the report offers strategic recommendations for advancing TVET, a crucial component for Nigeria's socioeconomic development and youth empowerment. This publication is an indispensable resource for those dedicated to enhancing the quality and relevance of technical vocational education in Nigeria, thus propelling the nation's workforce development and economic advancement. This report is a vital resource for anyone seeking to improve the quality and relevance of technical vocational education in Nigeria, therefore contributing to the nation's workforce development and economic progress.

nzeruka nnah

s: This paper examined the concept of Vocational and Technical Education (VTE) in Nigeria under secondary school education system. The meanings of Vocational Education, Technical Education and Vocational and Technical Education were discussed. Objectives of Vocational and Technical Education in secondary school education as contained in the National Policy on Education 2004 edition were highlighted. The scope/structure of Vocational and Technical Education in secondary school education was outlined. A concise historical development of Vocational and Technical Education at secondary school level was traced. Out of the numerous challenges of Vocational and Technical Education in general and Accounting Education in particular, some were identified and solutions were provided for the identified challenges. Recommendations were advanced to improve on the programme of Vocational and Technical Education in Nigeria such as inclusion of practical oriented curriculum, government should increase funding of education at all levels.

Asia Proceedings of Social Sciences

Dauda Ibrahim

The implementation of Technical Vocational Education and Training (TVET) curriculum requires some level of government commitment because of it nature and important towards reducing unemployment. Technical vocational education is a skill acquisition intervention programs that target about learning wisdom which would make people appropriate and productive in designated areas of economic and technological activities. In order to meet the demand of this 21st century implementation of technical vocational education curriculum in Nigeria must in totality be overhauled by ensuring that what is needed to achieve its goal is put in place for positive outcome. This paper discusses the concept of technical vocational education and training and it’s important towards job creation, the nature of technical vocational education curriculum in technical vocational education institutions, technical vocational education curriculum implementation and the impediments of Technical vocational education c...

RELATED PAPERS

Sebastián Riccheri

Isaac Casanovas-Vilar

Contraception

Jully Chilambwe

Jurnal Riwayat Pendidikan Sejarah

Akhmad Rakhman

Arxiv preprint arXiv: …

Lorena Monserrath Martínez Tovar

Ximena Julissa Lozano Heredia

Nafisatul 'Ula

European Journal of Taxonomy

Kader Fofana

Ahmar Metastasis Health Journal

ashar abilowo

Research, Society and Development

Rodrigo Andraus

MOHAMED AMINE ENNOUHI

Revista argentina de cardiología

Jorge Thierer

Drug and Alcohol Dependence

Ajay Manhapra

Proceedings of the 2016 Federated Conference on Computer Science and Information Systems

Rubén Fuentes-fernández

Revista Facultad Nacional De Agronomia

Pablo Elias Buritica Cespedes

Environmental Monitoring and Assessment

Martin Thoms

The journal of pediatric academy

Zahide Ekici Tekin

Sustainability

Carlos Smaniotto Costa

Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations

Itai Shafrir

Natura Croatica

Antun Alegro

Revue des Maladies Respiratoires Actualités

Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências

Edvane Borges

Nisrina Mardhiyyatul Hasanah

The Types of Colleges: The Basics

Find the right college for you., sorting out colleges by their types.

Is a college the same thing as a university? What does "liberal arts" mean? Why are some colleges called public and others private? Knowing the basics in regard to different types of colleges is imperative to making the right decision.

Public and Private Colleges

Public colleges are funded by local and state governments and usually offer lower tuition rates than private colleges, especially for students who are residents of the state where a college is located.

Private colleges rely on tuition, fees, and non-government funding sources. Generous financial aid packages for students are often available thanks to private donations.

For-Profit Colleges

For-profit institutions are businesses that typically offer career training. Although these colleges offer a variety of degree programs, it's wise to exercise caution when applying to a for-profit school. The degree programs often come at a higher cost, meaning students graduate with more debt. Credits earned may not transfer to other colleges so be sure to check with the admissions office at each institution.

Four-year and two-year colleges

Four-year institutions are referred to as undergraduate colleges. Four-year colleges specifically offer bachelor's degree programs. These include universities and liberal arts colleges.

Two-year colleges offer certificate programs that can be completed in under two years. They also offer two-year associate degrees. These include community colleges, vocational-technical colleges, and career colleges.

Liberal Arts Colleges

These institutions offer numerous courses in liberal arts in areas such as literature, history, languages, mathematics, and life sciences. Most of these institutions are private and offer four-year bachelor's degree programs. These colleges prepare students for a multiplicity of careers as well as graduate studies

Universities

Universities are larger institutions that offer a wider variety of academic majors and degree options. These schools provide bachelor's, master's, and doctoral degrees. Most universities contain several smaller colleges, such as colleges of education, engineering, or health sciences. These colleges can prepare you for a wide range of careers or for graduate study.

Community Colleges

Community colleges offer two-year associate degrees that prepare undergraduates for four-year institutions offering bachelor programs. They also provide career-specific associate degrees and certificates. Community colleges are an affordable option because of their low tuition costs.

What is the difference between a college and a university?

A college is a smaller school that may offer a wide variety of educational programs or more focused specializations for those seeking undergraduate degrees. Standing alone or as part of a larger institution, a college is often a private institution with a lower student population and smaller class sizes. On the other hand, a university is a larger school offering both undergraduate and graduate-level degrees. Because they’re a component of a university's doctoral programs, such institutions also serve as research facilities for educational advancement.

Vocational-Technical and Career Colleges

Vocational-technical and career colleges offer specialized training in a particular industry or career. Areas of study include the culinary arts, firefighting, dental hygiene, and medical-records technology. These colleges usually offer students certificates or associate degree programs.

Colleges with a Special Focus

Some colleges focus on a specific interest or student population. These include:

Arts colleges
Single-sex colleges
Religiously affiliated colleges
Specialized mission colleges

Arts Colleges

Conservatories and colleges of this variety focus on the arts. In addition to regular coursework, these institutions provide training in areas such as photography, music, theater, sculpture, drawing, or fashion design. Most of these schools offer associate or bachelor's degrees in the fine arts or a specialized field.

Single-Sex Colleges

Some private colleges are specifically for men or women.

Religiously Affiliated Colleges

Some private, higher-education institutions are connected to a religious faith. Such connections may simply be historic in nature. Others incorporate religious study into day-to-day student life.

Specially Designated Colleges

Historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) focus on educating African American students. Colleges and universities are designated Hispanic-serving institutions (HSIs) when at least 25% of the full-time undergraduate students are Hispanic. HBCUs and HSIs may offer programs, services, and activities targeted to the underrepresented students they serve.

What is better, a university or a college?

Those who prefer a more intimate experience with a greater connection to faculty may prefer a college. However, a university may be better for those looking for a broader range of programs and more learning facilities. The ultimate answer will depend on your personal preferences and the school in question. Both colleges and universities can provide a rewarding educational experience.

What to Do Now That You Know About the Different Types of Colleges

Now that you’re familiar with the types of institutions available, you should decide which one will suit your future goals. It’s often helpful to create a vision board of what you plan to achieve before deciding how you plan to achieve it. Take some time to think about your trajectory while keeping the knowledge of these various types of schools in mind. If you need direction after you assess your needs, you may find it helpful to talk to your school's guidance office, a college recruiter, or a college alum to work through any other questions you might have.

Embarking on a journey through higher education can be both exciting and challenging. Using the information presented here should help you sift through your options so the decisions you make today will serve you better in the future. For more help finding the right colleges for you, check out College Search .

UBTEB calls for review of TVET policy on special needs education

___________

KAMPALA - The Uganda Business and Technical Examination Board (UBTEB) has called for support in a bid to increase capacity for training and assessment of people with special education needs (SNE) in vocational education.

"As the board, we have the capacity because we started sometime back to recruit (SNE) staff and train them, but the challenge we see which we have brought to the attention of the Ministry of Education and Sports as the in charge of policy and delivery is that when you go to the training institutions (you will find that) is it was not thought of to consider SNE, " said Onesmus Oyesigye, the executive secretary UBTEB.

"We are discussing with them and we will give a report back (to the ministry). We want to see instructors who have been specifically trained to handle these students."

He was speaking to journalists ahead of the UBTEB exams which commence Monday, May 13, 2024, at the Secretariat headquarters in Ntinda in Kampala on Saturday.

According to him, while they have now acquired equipment for the assessment of the SNE candidates there is a need for training institutions to play a proper part in training if the country is to achieve inclusive education in technical vacation and education training (TVET).

He said as part of enhancing inclusive education, the Board has registered a total of 118 candidates with special needs (69 male and 49 female) pursuing various TVET professions.

Of these candidates, 66 candidates will require special attention. The Special Needs Education (SNE) cases include; dyslexia, visual impairment (blindness), hard of hearing (deaf), and physical disability.

He said the Special needs candidates will be accorded special examination arrangements such as sign language interpreters and transcribers, while others will be accorded an extra 30 minutes.

"The Board has accordingly deployed 66 support personnel to assist candidates with special needs," he said.

In total thare are 32,726 candidates students out of which 17,357 candidates are female and 15,369 are male are sitting exams at 294 exam centres across the country.

The exams start on Monday and will conclude on June 14.

Under the TVET Policy 2019, the Government recognizes that effective technical skills are vital for the individual, enterprise, and the economy since they lead to self-reliance at the family level, increased productivity, profits, and higher incomes for the nation.

This is in a bid to support the creation of needed employable skills and competencies relevant to the national transformational labour market as opposed to just the acquisition of educational certificates.

Under the policy, the government targets all Ugandans in need of skills for employment.

IMAGES

(PDF) Relevance of Technical and Vocational Education and Training as a
Sample research paper with literature review
(PDF) Work Placements in Vocational Education and Training Courses
(PDF) TECHNICAL VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING INSTITUTE -ADDIS
(PDF) Practical subjects in the vocational curriculum: A critical
Recommendations for confronting vocational education dropout: a

VIDEO

Entrepreneurial learning for TVET institutions: An introduction to the practical guide
UNESCO-UNEVOC webinar on Digital Competence and the Future of Work
BILT
The role of TVET in supporting gender equality and empowerment
TVET for Climate Action
list of vocational subject and core academic subject of cbse board class 10 and 12

COMMENTS

An Assessment Approaches and Learning Outcomes in Technical and ...
Technical and vocational education and training (TVET) assessments give precise feedback on whether students have successfully attained learning outcomes. It can improve teaching quality and empower students, educators, and stakeholders to take action. Only a few studies have attempted to review the literature on this topic systematically. The PRISMA (preferred reporting items for systematic ...
(PDF) Students' Interests in Technical and Vocational Education and
Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) has been widely acknowledged as one of the most important subjects in the educational system. ... literature review, a systematic review that ...
International organisations in vocational education and training: a
Although international organisations (IOs) are recognised as important actors in education, their involvement in vocational education and training (VET) remains underexamined. This article reviews the current state of research on IOs in VET, focusing on the ILO, OECD, UNESCO, and the World Bank, through an integrative literature review of 174 ...
ICT Enabled TVET Education: A Systematic Literature Review
Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) is an educational stream that provides vocational skills to youth and produces a skilled workforce for the industry. ... The result of this systematic literature review identifies that ICT technologies and application dispersion into TVET training cycle system components/functional areas is ...
Technical and vocational education and training (TVET ...
The world is facing a worsening youth employment crisis. In response, technical and vocational education and training (TVET) is back on the development agenda after years of neglect. This systematic review examined the evidence from studies evaluating the impacts of TVET interventions for young people in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The 26 included studies evaluated 20 different ...
Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) Interventions to
This review set out to examine the potential of technical and vocational education and training to improve the employment and employability of young people in developing countries. A comprehensive search for published and unpublished studies yielded 3 RCT studies and 23 quasi-experimental studies that met the inclusion criteria.
International transfer of vocational education and training: a
The transferability of vocational education and training (VET) systems is a central issue within international comparative VET research. However, scholars working in related disciplines also focus on the international cooperation associated with VET. This literature review presents relevant findings from the field of VET research, but also from ...
Vocational teachers' professional learning: A systematic literature
1. Introduction. Vocational teachers play a crucial role in ensuring vocational graduates' competitiveness in the labour market. To raise the quality of vocational education, vocational teachers are expected to seize opportunities to develop themselves, both inside and outside school (Dymock & Tyler, 2018; Schmidt, 2019; Virkkula & Nissilä, 2014).In recent years, the professional learning of ...
Career and Technical Education at Community Colleges: A Review of the
Abstract. I review the literature evaluating sub-baccalaureate career and technical education (CTE) at community colleges. The goal of this study is to review the evidence describing how earning these types of credentials affects students' outcomes, as well as which program characteristics contribute to student success.
Career and Technical Education as a Conduit for Skilled Technical
The term "career and technical education" means organized educational activities that (A) offer a sequence of courses that— (i) provides individuals with rigorous academic content and relevant technical knowledge and skills needed to prepare for further education and careers in current or emerging professions, which may include high-skill, high-wage, or in-demand industry sectors or ...
PDF An Assessment Approaches and Learning Outcomes in Technical and
Abstract: Technical and vocational education and training (TVET) assessments give precise feedback on whether students have successfully attained learning outcomes. It can improve teaching quality and empower students, educators, and stakeholders to take action. Only a few studies have attempted to review the literature on this topic ...
Guiding workplace learning in vocational education and training: a
This review provides an overview of the empirical research concerning guidance in the context of vocational education and training (VET). The study examines practices, providers and supporting and hindering factors related to guidance and learning at the workplace. After the inclusion/exclusion process, the final number of research articles included in this review is 18. Results show strong ...
A systematic literature review on the reform of vocational education in
Introduction. Vocational education is significant for Chinese education because, compared with basic education and general undergraduate education, vocational education has a closer relationship with economic and social development, aiming to cultivate technical and skilled personnel at the front line of the job to serve social and economic construction (Jia, Citation 2015).
(PDF) Assessing the Effectiveness of the Technical-Vocational
Availability of instructional materials model of the technical vocational livelihood curriculum implementation for public senior high schools. 2nd International Conference on Emerging Technology ...
ICT Enabled TVET Education: A Systematic Literature Review
In this RQ study, we found that 92.54% of the 124 papers did not focus on any speciﬁc industry in ICT-enabled TVET education. Only 10 documents which are 7.46% of a total of 134 selected literature have focused on any industry. The highest 2.99% focused industry is mechanical and electrical engineering.
Vocational education and training for African development: a literature
Stephanie Allais, Heila Lotz-Sisitka, David Monk, George Openjuru & Jo-Anna Russon (2019): Vocational education and training for African development: a literature review, Journal of Vocational ...
Literature Review Vocational Education and Training
Literature Review Vocational Education and Training. Education, Philosophy. The society which scorns excellence in plumbing because plumbing is a humble activity and tolerates shoddiness in philosophy because it is an exalted activity will have neither good plumbing nor good philosophies. Neither its pipes nor its theories will hold water (John ...
Technical and vocational education and training (TVET): report on the
191 EX/7 Executive Board Hundred and ninety-first session Item 7 of the provisional agenda TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING (TVET): REPORT ON THE FULL MID-TERM REVIEW OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE STRATEGY FOR TVET Summary Pursuant to 190 EX/Dec.8 (II), the Director-General reports to the Executive Board on the full mid-term review of the implementation of the Strategy for ...
Vocational Education and Training
This view is confirmed by Temple (2007) in a review of the literature, demonstrating that any connections between the learning environment and educational activities lack firm evidence. Even less research is focused on space issues in vocational education and training (VET) facilities and skill attainment. 13.
Jordan Technical and Vocational Education and Training System Review
The Review aimed to guide the implementation of MoE's technical and vocational education and training (TVET) reforms and inform on the relevance, effectiveness, impact, and sustainability of vocational education outcomes compared to active labour-market needs.
A Literature Review Technical and vocational education Abstract
Technical and vocational education is considered as an important measure for the development of trained labor force which are required for the economic growth of a country. The aim of this paper is to examine the problems and strategies for revamping ... A Literature Review Technical and vocational education Abstract. Mustapha O L A Y I W O L A ...
PDF An Evaluation of the Technical Vocational Livelihood Track in ...
Literature Review . The Technical-Vocational Education and Training . It is the preparation of persons in the secondary level to enter upon employment in the area of occupation where students are trained and best suited (Castillo, 2012). On the other hand, technical education prepares individuals who have gone through the secondary high school
Vocational education and training for African development: a literature
Whilst there has been much technical policy literature on VET in Africa (e.g. Atchoarena and Delluc Citation 2002; Johanson and Adams Citation 2004; SADC and UNESCO, Citation 2013), there are small strands of research on the vocational education system that are less focused on efficiency-focused policy reform, and more on critique.
Technical-Vocational Livelihood Education: Emerging Trends in
Technical-Vocational Livelihood Education(TVLE) Strategies and Indicators (S&Is) are the strategic procedures needed to come up with a well-informed contextualised learning instruction.
Gamification and Game Based Learning for Vocational Education and
The purpose of this study is to map the emerging trends of gamification and game-based learning (GBL) in the Vocational and Education Training (VET) sector. For this purpose, a Systematic Literature Review was conducted through the three most relevant scientific databases -- Web of Science, Scopus, ScienceDirect, and PubMed with Google Scholar ...
New Report Finds Positive Effects of Career and Technical Education on
A new report finds that students who participated in career and technical education (CTE) programs in high school were more likely to be employed after high school than similar classmates who did not participate in CTE. The report, "What We Know About the Impact of Career and Technical Education: A Systematic Review of the Research," was produced by experts from AIR through the federally ...
Understanding the Different Types of Colleges
Vocational-Technical and Career Colleges. Vocational-technical and career colleges offer specialized training in a particular industry or career. Areas of study include the culinary arts, firefighting, dental hygiene, and medical-records technology. These colleges usually offer students certificates or associate degree programs.
Rule 281-46.6
Rule 281-46.6 - [Effective 5/22/2024] Career and technical education program approval and review (1) Secondary program approval. All career and technical education programs offered by a district are to be approved by the department. As a condition for approval, a district will comply with the following paragraphs: a. Data collection and analysis.
Technical Vocational Education in the Philippines for Sustainable
Technical vocational education and training (TVET) refers to a deliberate intervention to bring about learning which would make people more relevant and productive in designated areas of economic ...
UBTEB calls for review of TVET policy on special needs education
_____KAMPALA - The Uganda Business and Technical Examination Board (UBTEB) has called for support in a bid to increase capacity for training and assessment of people with special education needs ...