The Foreign policy of Pakistan: issues, challenges, and solutions
- Naseem khan
- January 28, 2022
- CSS , CSS Solved Pakistan Affairs , Current Affairs , Featured , Opinions , Pakistan's Domestic Affairs , Pakistani Society , PMS
- 41069 Views
The foreign policy of Pakistan: issues, challenges, and solutions | Best for CSS, PMS Current Affairs, Pakistan Affairs, and Essay Papers
The answer is solved on the given pattern, which Sir Syed Kazim Ali teaches to his students, who consistently score the maximum because of their attempting the questions. The content is based on historical facts taught by Miss Nirmal Hasni , current affairs coach and Sir Rameez Ch Pakistan Affairs coach helping aspirants for years.
Introduction
With various issues: political instability, less coordination among state institutions, and poor economy, it can be contesting for Pakistan to manage its internal and external challenges, like the Kashmir problem, the US-India nexus, the arm-race in South Asia and establishing peace in Afghanistan. However, to make itself influential based on its foreign policy in the competitive world, Pakistan has to maintain good relations with its neighbours, confidence in all super-powers, and curb non-state actors.
What is meant by the foreign policy?
The foreign policy of Pakistan
Fundamental principles of Pakistan’s foreign policy
- To protect its sovereignty
- To maintain good relations with the Muslim world
- To observe the principle of non-interference
- To implement the UN Charter
- To support self-determination
Current scenario of Pakistan foreign policy
Challenges to Pakistan’s foreign policy
- Existing political instability
- Increasing Balochistan conundrum
- Prevailing terrorism and sectarianism
- Non-solving Kashmir problem
- Growing nexus of US-India
- Hanging sword of FATF
- Defaming the international Image of Pakistan
- Establishing peace in Afghanistan
Issues in Pakistan foreign policy
- The minimum coordination among state institutions
- The issue of incompetent policymakers
- The presence of inept leadership
- The burden of geographical location
- The enigma of religious fundamentalism
Way forward
- To maintain good relations with all neighbours
- To initiate a balanced approach toward the Middle East countries
- To give equal weightage to all superpowers
- To refrain from interference in internal affairs of other countries
- To promote political stability
- To boost the economic condition
- To curb non-state actors
Critical analysis
Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Nothing in this globalized world for a modern country is as important as sound foreign relations to secure its geographical, economic, and ideological interests. Living in isolation is no more in the interests of a country. Therefore, every developed or developing country has to formulate a peaceful and objective-oriented foreign policy keeping in view its national interests. Being a developing country, Pakistan enjoys its own effective and productive foreign policy based on its security and economic motives. It entertains cordial relations with all countries of the world. However, Pakistan faces several challenges regarding its foreign relations regarding the Kashmir issue, Indian aggressiveness, war-torn Afghanistan, the Middle East crisis, and a few more. These hurdles seem impossible to be managed by Pakistan in the presence of multiple issues such as fragile policies, a weak economy, a vulnerable geographical location, and the presence of non-state actors. In short, if Pakistan intends to formulate a successful foreign policy and manage its internal and external impediments, it has to eradicate all issues related to its economic, political, and ideological interests.
“Domestic policy can only defeat us; foreign policy can kill us.” John F. Kennedy
Foreign policy is the total of objectives, principles, and interests that a state keeps in view establishing its peaceful relations with other countries. Professor Joseph Frankel has aptly said, “Foreign policy consists of decisions and actions that involve relations between one state and others to some appreciable extent.” Moreover, it reflects domestic policies by which a country extends its relations to other sovereign nations. That is why the foreign policy of one state has profound effects on the neighbouring countries. Hence, Pakistan should make itself a stable country economically and politically to establish sound interactions with other countries.
Having hostile neighbours on both eastern and western sides, Pakistan’s foreign policy is mainly revolved around its key concerns, such as preserving its sovereignty, protecting its territorial integrity, and promoting the well-being of its people through economic development. Besides, Pakistan believes in maintaining good relations with all other countries on the basis of equality. Moreover, Pakistan has been the focal point of international politics owing to its geographical location. Being a gateway connecting many countries, Pakistan’s foreign policy can determine the fate of the region and affect international stability. Hence, Pakistan should formulate a peaceful foreign policy to secure its national interests in the best possible way.
“Success in foreign policy, as in carpentry, requires the right tool for the job.” Richard N. Haass
Fundamental principles of Pakistan’s foreign policy
Being a self-reliant state, the foreign policy of Pakistan is based on some essential principles. In the first place, Pakistan’s foreign policy at all costs ensures the sovereignty and independence of the country. Pakistan is the outcome of the great sacrifices of millions of Muslims, and that is why freedom of the country has become an integral part of its foreign policy. Second, Pakistan always seeks to maintain strong relations with all Muslim countries. For this very purpose, Pakistan has joined many organizations of Muslim countries to enhance its relationship with them. Third, Pakistan’s foreign policy is based on the principle of non-interference; thus, it never meddles in the internal affairs of other countries unless they invite it. Fourth, Pakistan does not ignore the UN Charter while formulating its foreign policy. It always supports all the moves of the UN in true essence. Lastly, Pakistan’s foreign policy is based on the principle of self-determination. Hence, it fights orally for the independence of Kashmir and Palestine based on this very principle.
Various internal and external challenges surround the foreign policy of Pakistan. Political instability in the country implements Pakistan’s foreign policy problematic for political stability is the hallmark of vibrant and efficient foreign policy. Moreover, the Balochistan issue is another internal hurdle in the way of Pakistan’s foreign policy. It limits the thinking capacity of policymakers because their minds stick to internal affairs only. Moreover, terrorism, extremism and sectarianism in the country have further jeopardized Pakistan’s foreign policy. Besides internal ones, external challenges are more dangerous as they directly influence Pakistan’s foreign policy development. The most crucial challenge among them is the Kashmir problem, for this very issue has been complicating the foreign relations of Pakistan and India since their independence. No one is ready to compromise on their interests related to Kashmir because it is the best water source for both of them. Furthermore, the US-India nexus and culture of the arms race in South Asia are giving a tough time to Pakistan’s foreign policy. Additionally, the sword of FATF, along with a bad image of Pakistan, are creating more impediments in the way of Pakistan’s foreign policy. Lastly, establishing peace in Afghanistan is the most exciting challenge for the Foreign Ministry of Pakistan. Hence, all these internal and external challenges contain the smooth progress of Pakistan’s foreign policy.
“How can I play baseball when I’m worried about foreign policy.” Charles M. Schulz
Issues in the foreign policy of Pakistan
The foreign policy of Pakistan cannot protect the national interests of Pakistan properly in the presence of various issues. First, less or no coordination among the state institutions and intelligence agencies leaves Pakistan’s foreign policy at the mercy of the Foreign Ministry only. Thus, there remain many loopholes while formulating it. Second, incompetent policymakers and inept leadership frame opportunistic foreign policies that are not long-lasting; therefore, these policies are insufficient to attain the country’s national interests. Third, the geographical location of Pakistan makes it more complicated for the Foreign Ministry of Pakistan to analyze satisfactory regional and global changing interests. Lastly, religious fundamentalists inside the country influence Pakistan’s foreign policy for their vicious interests. In short, all these issues play a significant role in making Pakistan’s foreign policy directionless and problematic.
Way forward
Pakistan must take concrete measures to make its foreign policy vibrant and effective. In the first place, Pakistan should maintain better relations with all its neighbouring countries, especially India and Afghanistan. For this reason, Pakistan must at all costs resolve all its problems with these countries like the issue of Kashmir. Next to it, Pakistan has to adopt a balanced approach toward all Middle East countries. Therefore, it must engage itself with all these countries equally. Besides, Pakistan must take all superpowers of the world, especially the US, China, and Russia. All of them are equally important for preserving the national interests of Pakistan. Apart from it, Pakistan should not meddle in the internal affairs of other countries and always stick to the UN Charter.
Additionally, Pakistan has to improve its political stability to give extra focus to internal affairs. Furthermore, moving ahead, Pakistan must improve its economic condition to pursue good relations with other countries equally. Lastly, Pakistan must take stringent actions against all non-state actors roaming inside the country so that they cannot degrade the international image of Pakistan. In this way, Pakistan can make itself influential with the help of a vibrant and well-organized foreign policy in this competitive world.
“Here is my first principle of foreign policy: good governance at home.” William E. Gladstone
The foreign policy works as a building block for a country to initiate good relations with other countries. Without a durable and effective foreign policy, a country can’t engage itself successfully with other countries. Every country must change its foreign policy with time as there is no permanent friends or foe in the international arena. That is why Pakistan should maintain exemplary relations with other countries based on an objective-oriented foreign policy. In this way, Pakistan can secure its national interest abroad effectively.
To conclude, the foreign policy of Pakistan is surrounded by multiple challenges. These challenges make it difficult for Pakistan’s foreign policy to preserve the country’s national interest. That is why Pakistan is at loggerheads with many nations due to its short-sighted foreign policy. These hurdles cannot be managed fruitfully by Pakistan unless the existing issues related to foreign policy are resolved. Only then Pakistan can live peacefully with other nations based on its durable foreign policy, and it can protect its national interest in the best possible way.
Want to read CSS Pakistan Affairs Solved Past Papers and learn how to attempt them to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers’ questions have been attempted by Sir Kazim’s students, who scored the highest in the subject. CSS Solved Pakistan Affairs
More Essays
Click on any to start reading the essay.
Want to read General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Miss Iqra Ali & Dr Nishat Baloch , Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students. General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers
Articles Might Interest You!
The following are some of the most important articles for CSS and PMS aspirants. Click on any to start reading.
Recent Posts
Top Categories
Cssprepforum, education company.
cssprepforum.com
Welcome to Cssprepforum, Pakistan’s largest learning management system (LMS) with millions of questions along with their logical explanations educating millions of learners, students, aspirants, teachers, professors, and parents preparing for a successful future.
Founder: Syed Kazim Ali Founded: 2020 Phone: +92-332-6105-842 +92-300-6322-446 Email: [email protected] Students Served: 10 Million Daily Learners: 50,000 Offered Courses: Visit Courses
More Courses
Basic English Grammar and Writing Course
Extensive English Essay & Precis Course for CSS and PMS
CSS English Essay and Precis Crash Course for 2023
Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox.
- CSS Solved Essays
- CSS Solved GSA
- CSS Solved PA
- CSS Solved Islamiat
- Current Affairs
- All Courses
- Writers Club
- All Authors
- All Members
- All Teachers
- Become an Author
- Who is Sir Syed Kazim Ali?
- Privacy Policy
CssPrepForum is Pakistan’s largest and greatest platform for CSS, PMS, FPSC, PPSC, SPSC, KPPSC, AJKPSC, BPSC, GBPSC, NTS, and other One Paper 100 Marks MCQs exams’ students. It has become Pakistan’s most trusted website among CSS, PMS students for their exams’ preparation because of its high-quality preparation material.
@ 2023 Cssprepforum. All RightsReserved.
Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser .
Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
pakistan foreign policy
Related Papers
Pakistan’s foreign policy is turning a new leaf. Perhaps for the first time in 70 years the regional and global dynamics have allowed Pakistan to make foreign policy choices that are not a construct of regional global constraints and compulsions. This has direct manifestations for the bilateral equation of conflict with India. The relationship that Pakistan have with India, it’s not just about peace in South Asia. It is intrinsically linked to the global struggle against terror, violent extremism and peace in Afghanistan to name a few. Pakistan is and will remain a pivot state in the region. The paradigm shift in Pakistan’s foreign policy from geo-politics to geo-economics has the following dimensions: • Direct stakes in conflict resolution, peace and stability in the region • Strategic economic convergence with China • Improved relations with Iran and Russia • Desire for a functional relationship with India • A balanced relationship with Washington and Riyadh Pakistan is fast becoming a country investing in economic growth, regional connectivity and peace. The policy thrust of Pakistan is focused on neutralizing conflicts inside its territory and improving relations with its neighbors. The theoretical construct of Pakistan’s foreign policy is that it is a security state exercising defensive realism.
Pakistan Journal of International Affairs
sayeda daud
Pakistan has a long history of economic and political instability despite being an ally of the west. All national and external decisions were dependent on the interests of these powers. Pakistan never had the opportunity to establish either a strong democratic government or to pursue any independent, foreign relations since 1947specially during Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, in December, 1979. Despite of sacrificing lives of many of her citizens during the War on Terror after 9/11, instead of appreciation form the West especially the US, Pakistan was labeled as a terrorist and an extremist Muslim Country. Kept isolated from the International Community, Pakistan was left no choice but to look for a more regional ally with common interests. Joining hands with China, the most trusted friend and an economic giant, seemed the only option. In this way, Pakistan hoped to play a better international role by having relations with all players in the region. To find out the root causes of the...
Pakistan's foreign policy has always been identified as policy of self-abnegation. It is blamed that external factors particularly USA play a vital role in the shaping of foreign policy of Pakistan but there are many internal factors pose challenges to Pakistan's foreign policy. Pakistan is an ideological state hence ideology has a special place in its foreign policy and it has been a central focus in the foreign policy for all time. There is a famous U-turn in Pakistan's foreign policy in recent era and this shift in policy has provoked an intense debate at home and abroad. Territorial integrity is the foremost important foreign policy goal of any country and it deals with the security that may be external or internal or both. Similarly, most important issue in Pakistan's foreign policy is security concerns because Pakistan has one of the most complex threat analyses of any state in the world. There are many problems at home related to grievances against foreign policy particularly on the issue and pattern of war on terrorism. This paper deals with the theoretical aspect of term foreign policy and analyzes the Pakistan's foreign policy with special reference to the issue of security. What are the threats and challenges to the security of Pakistan and what are modern trends adopted by Pakistan to counter these security threats. A detailed analysis has been given of domestic challenges in making an effective foreign policy like radical Islam and regional separatism, terrorism, WANA issue and remnants of Al-Qaeda and the Taliban. Foreign Policy: Foreign policy can be said to have emerged when contacts between the earliest human societies took place 1. Foreign policy behavior refers to the actions states take toward each other. It is important to note that these actions usually are not taken as ends in themselves but are tied in some way to larger purposes-from long run aspirations to more immediate aims-that national leaders hope to achieve in their dealings with other countries 2. There is a dire need for theory of foreign policy that is separate from the theory of international relations. A society constituted by the individuals and evolved with the
Mutassaf Naqeeb
The Muslim World
Global Regional Review
Muhammad Muzaffar
Pakistan is a state like other states of the world. When it came out from the British net the initial stages were very tough for it. It was considered that it will rejoin India. But the administration of that time took sincere initiatives to manage the affairs gradually. Cold war started at that time between the Communist and Capitalist blocks. Newly established states joined one of them. Pakistan was also one of them. Its foreign policy principles, rules and regulations are highlighted in this paper. All these steps are discussed below gradually with the help of primary and secondary sources. It is concluded that Pakistan had no choice to join the capitalist block because of its financial position that forced it to take such decisions as compared to India. But security and sovereignty were never compromised in every era and at every stage.
Mazher Hussain , M Anwar Farooq
This study deals with the dimensions of Pakistan's foreign policy right from its inception in 1947 up to the 9/11 Incident. Being a founding father of the nation Quaid-i-Azam set the directions for all departments of the newly born state including its foreign policy. Later on the policy was further developed by the first Prime Minister of Pakistan Liaqat Ali Khan and the Foreign Minister of Pakistan Zaffarullah Khan. The regional and international challenges resulted in Pakistan's alliance and reliance on the US and the Western World. Consequently Pakistan joined the US sponsored pacts i.e. SEATO and CENTO in 1954 and 1955 respectively. In 1960s Pakistan's relations with China were developed and border agreement was signed between the two countries in 1963 and during Indo-Pak War of 1965 China supported Pakistan on all stages. In 1970s Pakistan's foreign policy saw the new dimensions in the wake of separation of East Pakistan 1979and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan 1979. These developments influenced Pakistan greatly and brought Pakistan in the laps of US and the Western World. On the other hand cordial and friendly relations were also developed with the Muslim World especially the Arabs. Likewise Pakistan's stance over Nuclear Issue in 1990s, Kargil Crisis and 9/11 Incident is one of the hot issues of present study.
Syed Jameel
As a rule, foreign policy of a state, is an extension or a reflection of its internal policy. Since Pakistan emerged as an Islamic State, its internal policy was deemed to be committed to the establishment of a just socio-moral order in this country (in consonance with the socio teachings of Islam). By implication, its foreign policy should likewise have been reflective of the same ideological commitment. It means that Pakistan should have only one overriding objective: Establishment of a just socio-moral order in Pakistan, and a just socio-moral order around the globe. It means that Pakistan should have been a party to those who are striving for justice and be opposed to those who are spreading corruption and exploitation at the international level. In this brief article, we will try to analyse as to how far we have been faithful to our ideological moorings. And if we have deviated, which indeed we did, then what steps should be taken to rectify this departure.
Masoud Amin
Foreign policy analysis as a field of study is categorized by its actor-specific focus. It is the study of the procedure, outcomes, origins, or outputs of foreign policy decision-making in either a comparative or case-specific manner. Foreign Policy Analysis bestows an accessible opportunity of research publication which boosts communication through theoretical, methodological, geographical and disciplinary limits, exposing the divergent, comparative and multidisciplinary nature of the field. Indeed, one finds a synergy of foreign policy studies for historians increasingly interesting as international relations move towards its own discipline. The tools of decision-making analysis are readily adaptable to detailed cases, and opening up many state archives has made it impossible to avoid the evidence of such pathologies as bureaucratic politics or small group dynamics. For a country like Pakistan, foreign policy needs to demonstrate political will and military power to have friendly relations in order to keep a check, for example, on a hostile India, the former Soviet Union, and present day terrorist threats. It also needs to perfect democratic practice. This can be synchronized by a foreign policy with a prudent realism. To conclude, it can be argued that one country’s domestic problems can be another country’s solutions. Domestic politics is the reflection of a country’s foreign policy. Another country might be gaining a lot from a particular regime while the indigenous people governed under that regime may ultimately be suffering. This is particularly so where states are intensively connected, whether through security alliances or strategic partnerships. The institutional interaction between the US and Pakistan is the best example to quote here. The Pakistan Army was hard in domestic politics but was soft in its terms with the US, apart from those two periods, i.e., during the first half of 1960s and the post-Musharraf’s era of today.
RELATED PAPERS
Valerio Carando
Getúlio Braga Júnior
Journal of Physiological Anthropology
Mohammad Fararouei
Revista da ABENO
CYNTHIA FARIAS
Business Horizons
Gerard Tellis
Sleep Science
Mila Cunha c
Farah Aqilah
University of Pittsburgh Law Review
Donald Langevoort
Hafizha Azra Amalia
Hafizha Azra Amalia C1C020147
Oscar Perdomo
vyankatesh Dharanguttikar
Tatiana Bedrina
Vyacheslav Yurchenko
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS
Pratibha Nallari
Epidemiology, risk factors for disease or disease progression
Wilson Bautista
Muhammad Rashid Khan
Journal of gastrointestinal and liver diseases : JGLD
Ciprian Brisc
Roberto Luiz do Carmo
Saurabh Yadav
Concepción Nuñez
Aula abierta
Alicia Cardozo
International Astronomical Union Colloquium
Andrew Jacob
Freshwater Biology - FRESHWATER BIOL
Ortwin Renn
Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting
Dimitris Psychoyios
See More Documents Like This
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
- Find new research papers in:
- Health Sciences
- Earth Sciences
- Cognitive Science
- Mathematics
- Computer Science
- Academia ©2024
COMMENTS
Pakistan. Objectives and Determinants of Pakistan 's Foreign Policy. The concept of objectiv e, which is essentially an 'im age' of a future state of affairs. and future set of conditions ...
This is the capstone essay of a larger project that looks at Pakistan's medium-term future, defined as the next five to seven years (2012-2017). Other project elements include a
Zubeida Mustafa. Since July 1977, when the military government took over in Islamabad, Pakistani's foreign policy has been increasingly subject to the stresses strains generated by international politics in the region of which Pakistan. is a part. It has, like other small Third World powers with extremely.
basis of Pakistan's foreign policy with a comparative perspective. Pakistan's foreign policy is a case of certain domestic factors effectively coming at play with the international political environment. Over the years, it has ensued from the interplay of normative ideals prevailing in the country's organisational elite and masses, with
This idea was inherited by every successive Pakistani government as the cornerstone of its foreign policy. It is believed that "Ideology is an important determinant of foreign policy. Footnote 15 of the state of Pakistan. The substance of Pakistan's external policy was set down by the country's founding fathers on Islamic values.
This paper reviews the operational, institutional, and political factors that have shaped the conduct of foreign policy by the current regime during the first half of its five-year tenure. It underscores the strengths and issues that need to be acknowledged and properly tackled. Keywords: Pakistan, Foreign Policy, Imran Khan, PTI, Diplomacy.
Pakistan's foreign policy assist in exploring various issues and trends in Islamabad's external affairs vis-à-vis Muslim World, Great powers, and specifically its relations with regional neighbors - India, Iran and Afghanistan. ...
examples illuminating the role of soft power in Pakistan's foreign policy. Foreign Policy as Soft Power Resource Foreign policy is one of three basic resources of soft power. The other two primary resources are culture and political values.23 Foreign policy can be defined as ―the sum of official external relations conducted by an
This book analyses Pakistan's foreign policy and external relations with a focus on contemporary developments, including the impact of the new government of Prime Minister Imran Khan, the powerful military, and the "middle power" status. Structured in two parts - Foundation and Operationalization - the book provides a broad overview of ...
active foreign policy to deal with the changing dynamics of the region. An objective based foreign policy can maximise the advantage for Pakistan's strategic location despite all challenges. This article seeks to analyse in depth the importance of Pakistan's geographic and strategic location in the
Major Phases of Pakistan's Foreign Policy The major phases of Pakistan's foreign policy are: a. 1947-53: Explorations and friendship with all b. 1953-62: Alignment with the West c. 1962-71: Transition d. 1972-79: Bilateralism and nonalignment e. 1980-90: Afghanistan and Partnership with the U.S. f. 1990-2001: Post-Cold War Era and Pakistan's ...
Abstract. The shifting global order suggests arrival of the world away from the U.S.-led liberal unipolar order. The rise of the rest, notably, the Chinese vision reflected in its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has defied the U.S. global hegemony. For example, China's growing wealth and power, Russia's resurge and belligerence, Europe's ...
This research essay delves into the nuanced intricacies of Pakistan's foreign policy during the Musharraf regime (1999-2008), a period marked by geopolitical shifts and challenges. It explores key aspects, including the alliance with the United States, relations with India, regional dynamics, and economic diplomacy.
place in Pakistan's foreign policy. To allay any doubts and reservations on CPEC, President Xi reiterated that "Pakistan is our time tested iron friend and Pakistan Army has a pivotal role towards this lasting relationship", reassuring that "China shall continue to support Pakistan as a strategic partner", and "those
The foreign policy of Pakistan was laid on the principles of good will and friendly terms with neighboring countries and all the states of the world, with special importance to the Muslim world due to Islamic brotherhood. After the partition of 1947 Pakistan embarked on a new journey of independence but from a scratch.
Major Determinant's of Pakistan's external relations are: Internal/Domestic Determinants. Ideology based on Islamic principles. Historical background linked with Muslim rule of India. Social and political culture. Leadership and political organization. Military capability. Economic strength. Public opinion.
Jamshed Baloch. 2014. Foreign policy of Pakistan seems to have been facing grim challenges since the very existence of the country. Indeed the challenges posed in 21st century are more serious threat to the foreign policy and state of Pakistan. The challenges like the event of 9/11, globalization, extremism, terrorism and economic decline have ...
The foreign policy of Pakistan: issues, challenges, and solutions | Best for CSS, PMS Current Affairs, Pakistan Affairs, and Essay Papers. The answer is solved on the given pattern, which Sir Syed Kazim Ali teaches to his students, who consistently score the maximum because of their attempting the questions. The content is based on historical facts taught by Miss Nirmal Hasni, current affairs ...
The policy thrust of Pakistan is focused on neutralizing conflicts inside its territory and improving relations with its neighbors. The theoretical construct of Pakistan's foreign policy is that it is a security state exercising defensive realism. Download Free PDF. View PDF.